https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=417284

--- Comment #4 from Dan Leinir Turthra Jensen <ad...@leinir.dk> ---
(In reply to Nate Graham from comment #2)
> Sounds like an interesting feature. One thing we could do is maybe activate
> this feature automatically when you press the play button while the playlist
> is empty. Right now this does nothing, which is not amazing. Basically we
> could take a wild guess that the user is attempting to "just play literally
> any music!" when they do this.

  That's a good idea, yes! It would then need to be sufficiently obvious that
that is how they suddenly ended up with a playlist they seem unable to empty...
but yes, definitely sounds like a good idea :)

> How do you envision that set of random tracks would be chosen? from the
> entire library, or from the tracks in the current view?

  From the entire library, unless it's told something else... which i guess we
could argue might well be the current view. Perhaps there could be a banner in
the playlist view (which also makes it obvious that that mode is on), and gives
some options specific to it, such as a button to make the current view the new
source for music, and a "turn off autofill" button? Incidentally this would be
not entirely dissimilar to how Amarok's dynamic playlists worked (though
perhaps we don't need... quite that much crazy power ;) )

> Seems like we would also want the shuffle feature to actually visually
> shuffle the tracks in the global playlist, rather than leaving them in the
> original order in the list but choosing a random one every time a track
> finishes.

Yeah, shuffling has some very distinct semantics compared to random selection,
would be great to keep those intact :)

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are watching all bug changes.

Reply via email to