I've been reading the recent discussion here re HID vs. vendor specific classes with great interest. Like Rene, I am primarily a hardware designer. I plan to add USB connectivity to an existing product. BTW, I am also the firmware developer, chief marketer and bean counter!
The product is a proximity sensor, and is built around a Microchip PIC18F14K50, their low cost 20-pin device with USB connection. Though this device is not exactly human interactive, I initially planned to release this as a HID because it only transfers a few bytes of data, HID routines are included in Microchip's example code libraries, all OS's come with HID drivers, and it seems very simple to implement, at least on Windows. Statements such as the following seemed to validate my reasoning: "If you have the time and funds you can implement using “vendor defined” interfaces which are included within the USB specification as an option. But while you are moving along this difficult and time-consuming path don’t be surprised if your competitor introduces a similar product using a collection of standard drivers and captures most of the available customer base. I am a STRONG advocate of OS-supplied and vendor-supplied drivers and always recommend that everyone use this route. I maintain that you need an extremely compelling reason to embark on writing your own device driver; most people don’t." -- John Hyde, _Embedded USB Design by Example_ p. 13. But I want Mac and Linux app writers to be able to use this product with the same ease as Windows app writers. Peter Stuge makes a strong case for vendor-specific class devices. I am willing to go that route, but could use some help getting started. Pointers to resources would be appreciated... something like "USB vendor specific classes for dummies!" Thanks in advance, John -- -- http://www.fastmail.fm - Or how I learned to stop worrying and love email again _______________________________________________ libhid-discuss mailing list libhid-discuss@lists.alioth.debian.org http://lists.alioth.debian.org/mailman/listinfo/libhid-discuss http://libhid.alioth.debian.org/