Re: When's Trinidad/ADFFaces graduation?
Hi Mike, see some comments inline. On 2/4/07, Mike Kienenberger [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Speaking of incubator issues, what's holding up graduation of Trinidad at this point? From what I've seen, the community is active and understands the Apache way. I agree The status page appears to have checked off all of the outstanding tasks. The only relevent thing in the last board report (which is missing from the status page, by the way) was cleanup of notices and licenses for compliance with the ASF and there's no indication that any further incubating tasks are pending. http://wiki.apache.org/incubator/December2006 I overhauled the source files to met compliance w/ the ASF during the last month. all JARs now also contain the NOTICE.TXT and LICENSE.TXT As far as I know, the only thing that might be holding up graduation is a dry-run through a release, and that doesn't have to wait until there's a real release ready. Martin van den Bemt (our mentor) and me are working on that. I am fighting with a maven profile (see my next email) I'd be +1 on accepting Trinidad under MyFaces at this point. I am definitely +1 on that as well. (binding like yours from MyFaces PMC standpoint) How did you guys handle that with Cayenne ? Did you guys voted in your dev list on that?`Or just *asking* for graduation on the [EMAIL PROTECTED] list ? -Matthias -- Matthias Wessendorf http://tinyurl.com/fmywh further stuff: blog: http://jroller.com/page/mwessendorf mail: mwessendorf-at-gmail-dot-com
Re: When's Trinidad/ADFFaces graduation?
For graduation votes the following needs to happen : - Vote on this list for graduation - Vote on incubator general - The MyFaces PMC needs to vote to accept Trinidad (or the board if trinidad goes TLP) Before we start a vote however, I would still want to walk through this checklist http://incubator.apache.org/incubation/Incubation_Policy.html#Exiting+the+Incubator. Please don't start answering all things above yet, since it is something I want to figure out, since people on the incubator PMC would probably do the same and it's better that we hit the problem areas than when the vote on general happens. I will try to get the mail out to the dev in the coming week. Mvgr, Martin Matthias Wessendorf wrote: Hi Mike, see some comments inline. On 2/4/07, Mike Kienenberger [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Speaking of incubator issues, what's holding up graduation of Trinidad at this point? From what I've seen, the community is active and understands the Apache way. I agree The status page appears to have checked off all of the outstanding tasks. The only relevent thing in the last board report (which is missing from the status page, by the way) was cleanup of notices and licenses for compliance with the ASF and there's no indication that any further incubating tasks are pending. http://wiki.apache.org/incubator/December2006 I overhauled the source files to met compliance w/ the ASF during the last month. all JARs now also contain the NOTICE.TXT and LICENSE.TXT As far as I know, the only thing that might be holding up graduation is a dry-run through a release, and that doesn't have to wait until there's a real release ready. Martin van den Bemt (our mentor) and me are working on that. I am fighting with a maven profile (see my next email) I'd be +1 on accepting Trinidad under MyFaces at this point. I am definitely +1 on that as well. (binding like yours from MyFaces PMC standpoint) How did you guys handle that with Cayenne ? Did you guys voted in your dev list on that?`Or just *asking* for graduation on the [EMAIL PROTECTED] list ? -Matthias
Re: When's Trinidad/ADFFaces graduation?
For Cayenne, it was as Martin posted. First we voted on the project dev list, then we asked for an incubator PMC vote on general, then we waited for the board to approve Cayenne as a TLP. On 2/4/07, Matthias Wessendorf [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi Mike, see some comments inline. On 2/4/07, Mike Kienenberger [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Speaking of incubator issues, what's holding up graduation of Trinidad at this point? From what I've seen, the community is active and understands the Apache way. I agree The status page appears to have checked off all of the outstanding tasks. The only relevent thing in the last board report (which is missing from the status page, by the way) was cleanup of notices and licenses for compliance with the ASF and there's no indication that any further incubating tasks are pending. http://wiki.apache.org/incubator/December2006 I overhauled the source files to met compliance w/ the ASF during the last month. all JARs now also contain the NOTICE.TXT and LICENSE.TXT As far as I know, the only thing that might be holding up graduation is a dry-run through a release, and that doesn't have to wait until there's a real release ready. Martin van den Bemt (our mentor) and me are working on that. I am fighting with a maven profile (see my next email) I'd be +1 on accepting Trinidad under MyFaces at this point. I am definitely +1 on that as well. (binding like yours from MyFaces PMC standpoint) How did you guys handle that with Cayenne ? Did you guys voted in your dev list on that?`Or just *asking* for graduation on the [EMAIL PROTECTED] list ? -Matthias -- Matthias Wessendorf http://tinyurl.com/fmywh further stuff: blog: http://jroller.com/page/mwessendorf mail: mwessendorf-at-gmail-dot-com
When's Trinidad/ADFFaces graduation?
Speaking of incubator issues, what's holding up graduation of Trinidad at this point? From what I've seen, the community is active and understands the Apache way. The status page appears to have checked off all of the outstanding tasks. The only relevent thing in the last board report (which is missing from the status page, by the way) was cleanup of notices and licenses for compliance with the ASF and there's no indication that any further incubating tasks are pending. http://wiki.apache.org/incubator/December2006 As far as I know, the only thing that might be holding up graduation is a dry-run through a release, and that doesn't have to wait until there's a real release ready. I'd be +1 on accepting Trinidad under MyFaces at this point.
