RE: FW: SSH/SFTP rc problem in Solaris.
This is different than what you first posted -- it doesn't have an ls -l at the end, so it exits with a different error code. ___ Sent with SnapperMail www.snappermail.com .. Original Message ... On Tue, 9 May 2006 08:22:09 +0200 Dony Pierre [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi Patrick, When I do the test on a RedHat, I get a rc 1 !. [EMAIL PROTECTED] ~]$ cat a.sftp get tuut.test [EMAIL PROTECTED] ~]$ sftp -b a.sftp localhost [EMAIL PROTECTED]'s password: sftp get tuut.test Couldn't stat remote file: No such file or directory File /home/donypie/tuut.test not found. [EMAIL PROTECTED] ~]$ echo $? 1 [EMAIL PROTECTED] ~]$ But I have received news from Sun concerning this problem and they said that : Openssh sftp has changed in release 3.6p1, and *this* is why we are seeing different behaviour e.g. on a Linux distribution which bundles a sufficiently recent OpenSSH suite. These newer sftp binaries will indeed exit with a nonzero status when one of the batched subcommands did not succeed as requested, and of course they will still do so when they encounter a protocol-level error. I hope they will implement these new features in SSH Sun as soon as possible. Thanks everybody. Pierre. -Original Message- From: Patrick Morris [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: vendredi 5 mai 2006 21:27 To: secureshell@securityfocus.com Subject: RE: FW: SSH/SFTP rc problem in Solaris. Just tried this on a Red Hat box (EL4). I get a return code of 0 for the same commands. We have a SSH return code problem when we use SSH in batch in Solaris. We haven't this problem on RedHat. bash-2.05$ cat a.sftp ls -l pwd get b.txt ls -l bash-2.05$ sftp -b a.sftp scnsys11 Connecting to scnsys11... Password: sftp ls -l drwxr-xr-x0 9108 10512 Apr 21 11:15 . drwxr-xr-x0 01 512 Apr 3 14:23 .. -rw---0 9108 10 2387 Apr 21 11:18 ..bash_history -rw---0 9108 10240 Mar 28 16:19 .sh_history drwx--0 9108 10512 Mar 22 17:11 .ssh drwx--0 9108 10512 Mar 22 16:00 .ssh2 -rwxrwxrwx0 9108 10 26 Mar 29 15:22 a.sftp -rwxrwxrwx0 9108 10 0 Mar 28 15:28 a.txt -rw---0 9108 101021424 Mar 22 17:07 core sftp pwd Remote working directory: /export/home/huysego sftp get b.txt Couldn't stat remote file: No such file or directory File /export/home/huysego/b.txt not found. sftp ls -l drwxr-xr-x0 9108 10512 Apr 21 11:15 . drwxr-xr-x0 01 512 Apr 3 14:23 .. -rw---0 9108 10 2387 Apr 21 11:18 ..bash_history -rw---0 9108 10240 Mar 28 16:19 .sh_history drwx--0 9108 10512 Mar 22 17:11 .ssh drwx--0 9108 10512 Mar 22 16:00 .ssh2 -rwxrwxrwx0 9108 10 26 Mar 29 15:22 a.sftp -rwxrwxrwx0 9108 10 0 Mar 28 15:28 a.txt -rw---0 9108 101021424 Mar 22 17:07 core sftp bash-2.05$ echo $? 0 ** As you can see in this example, sftp gives a rc = 0. If you try the same on RedHat, you will receive a rc not equal to 0. - Visit our website! http://ww
RE: FW: SSH/SFTP rc problem in Solaris.
Hi Patrick, When I do the test on a RedHat, I get a rc 1 !. [EMAIL PROTECTED] ~]$ cat a.sftp get tuut.test [EMAIL PROTECTED] ~]$ sftp -b a.sftp localhost [EMAIL PROTECTED]'s password: sftp get tuut.test Couldn't stat remote file: No such file or directory File /home/donypie/tuut.test not found. [EMAIL PROTECTED] ~]$ echo $? 1 [EMAIL PROTECTED] ~]$ But I have received news from Sun concerning this problem and they said that : Openssh sftp has changed in release 3.6p1, and *this* is why we are seeing different behaviour e.g. on a Linux distribution which bundles a sufficiently recent OpenSSH suite. These newer sftp binaries will indeed exit with a nonzero status when one of the batched subcommands did not succeed as requested, and of course they will still do so when they encounter a protocol-level error. I hope they will implement these new features in SSH Sun as soon as possible. Thanks everybody. Pierre. -Original Message- From: Patrick Morris [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: vendredi 5 mai 2006 21:27 To: secureshell@securityfocus.com Subject: RE: FW: SSH/SFTP rc problem in Solaris. Just tried this on a Red Hat box (EL4). I get a return code of 0 for the same commands. We have a SSH return code problem when we use SSH in batch in Solaris. We haven't this problem on RedHat. bash-2.05$ cat a.sftp ls -l pwd get b.txt ls -l bash-2.05$ sftp -b a.sftp scnsys11 Connecting to scnsys11... Password: sftp ls -l drwxr-xr-x0 9108 10512 Apr 21 11:15 . drwxr-xr-x0 01 512 Apr 3 14:23 .. -rw---0 9108 10 2387 Apr 21 11:18 ..bash_history -rw---0 9108 10240 Mar 28 16:19 .sh_history drwx--0 9108 10512 Mar 22 17:11 .ssh drwx--0 9108 10512 Mar 22 16:00 .ssh2 -rwxrwxrwx0 9108 10 26 Mar 29 15:22 a.sftp -rwxrwxrwx0 9108 10 0 Mar 28 15:28 a.txt -rw---0 9108 101021424 Mar 22 17:07 core sftp pwd Remote working directory: /export/home/huysego sftp get b.txt Couldn't stat remote file: No such file or directory File /export/home/huysego/b.txt not found. sftp ls -l drwxr-xr-x0 9108 10512 Apr 21 11:15 . drwxr-xr-x0 01 512 Apr 3 14:23 .. -rw---0 9108 10 2387 Apr 21 11:18 ..bash_history -rw---0 9108 10240 Mar 28 16:19 .sh_history drwx--0 9108 10512 Mar 22 17:11 .ssh drwx--0 9108 10512 Mar 22 16:00 .ssh2 -rwxrwxrwx0 9108 10 26 Mar 29 15:22 a.sftp -rwxrwxrwx0 9108 10 0 Mar 28 15:28 a.txt -rw---0 9108 101021424 Mar 22 17:07 core sftp bash-2.05$ echo $? 0 ** As you can see in this example, sftp gives a rc = 0. If you try the same on RedHat, you will receive a rc not equal to 0. - Visit our website! http://www.nbb.be DISCLAIMER: The content of this e-mail message should not be construed as binding on the part of the National Bank of Belgium (NBB) unless otherwise and previously stated. The opinions expressed in this message are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect NBB viewpoints, particularly when the content of this message, or part thereof, is private by nature or does not fall within the professional scope of its author.
RE: FW: SSH/SFTP rc problem in Solaris.
Just tried this on a Red Hat box (EL4). I get a return code of 0 for the same commands. We have a SSH return code problem when we use SSH in batch in Solaris. We haven't this problem on RedHat. bash-2.05$ cat a.sftp ls -l pwd get b.txt ls -l bash-2.05$ sftp -b a.sftp scnsys11 Connecting to scnsys11... Password: sftp ls -l drwxr-xr-x0 9108 10512 Apr 21 11:15 . drwxr-xr-x0 01 512 Apr 3 14:23 .. -rw---0 9108 10 2387 Apr 21 11:18 .bash_history -rw---0 9108 10240 Mar 28 16:19 .sh_history drwx--0 9108 10512 Mar 22 17:11 .ssh drwx--0 9108 10512 Mar 22 16:00 .ssh2 -rwxrwxrwx0 9108 10 26 Mar 29 15:22 a.sftp -rwxrwxrwx0 9108 10 0 Mar 28 15:28 a.txt -rw---0 9108 101021424 Mar 22 17:07 core sftp pwd Remote working directory: /export/home/huysego sftp get b.txt Couldn't stat remote file: No such file or directory File /export/home/huysego/b.txt not found. sftp ls -l drwxr-xr-x0 9108 10512 Apr 21 11:15 . drwxr-xr-x0 01 512 Apr 3 14:23 .. -rw---0 9108 10 2387 Apr 21 11:18 .bash_history -rw---0 9108 10240 Mar 28 16:19 .sh_history drwx--0 9108 10512 Mar 22 17:11 .ssh drwx--0 9108 10512 Mar 22 16:00 .ssh2 -rwxrwxrwx0 9108 10 26 Mar 29 15:22 a.sftp -rwxrwxrwx0 9108 10 0 Mar 28 15:28 a.txt -rw---0 9108 101021424 Mar 22 17:07 core sftp bash-2.05$ echo $? 0 ** As you can see in this example, sftp gives a rc = 0. If you try the same on RedHat, you will receive a rc not equal to 0.
Re: FW: SSH/SFTP rc problem in Solaris.
The second ls -l command successfully completes. Therefore the return code is zero. We have a SSH return code problem when we use SSH in batch in Solaris. We haven't this problem on RedHat. bash-2.05$ cat a.sftp ls -l pwd get b.txt ls -l bash-2.05$ sftp -b a.sftp scnsys11 Connecting to scnsys11... Password: sftp ls -l drwxr-xr-x0 9108 10512 Apr 21 11:15 . drwxr-xr-x0 01 512 Apr 3 14:23 .. -rw---0 9108 10 2387 Apr 21 11:18 .bash_history -rw---0 9108 10240 Mar 28 16:19 .sh_history drwx--0 9108 10512 Mar 22 17:11 .ssh drwx--0 9108 10512 Mar 22 16:00 .ssh2 -rwxrwxrwx0 9108 10 26 Mar 29 15:22 a.sftp -rwxrwxrwx0 9108 10 0 Mar 28 15:28 a.txt -rw---0 9108 101021424 Mar 22 17:07 core sftp pwd Remote working directory: /export/home/huysego sftp get b.txt Couldn't stat remote file: No such file or directory File /export/home/huysego/b.txt not found. sftp ls -l drwxr-xr-x0 9108 10512 Apr 21 11:15 . drwxr-xr-x0 01 512 Apr 3 14:23 .. -rw---0 9108 10 2387 Apr 21 11:18 .bash_history -rw---0 9108 10240 Mar 28 16:19 .sh_history drwx--0 9108 10512 Mar 22 17:11 .ssh drwx--0 9108 10512 Mar 22 16:00 .ssh2 -rwxrwxrwx0 9108 10 26 Mar 29 15:22 a.sftp -rwxrwxrwx0 9108 10 0 Mar 28 15:28 a.txt -rw---0 9108 101021424 Mar 22 17:07 core sftp bash-2.05$ echo $? 0 ** As you can see in this example, sftp gives a rc = 0. If you try the same on RedHat, you will receive a rc not equal to 0.
Re: FW: SSH/SFTP rc problem in Solaris.
Hi dony, I see an error when the get command try get the file b.txt, because this file not exist!, what's the idea with this script? Regards, Marcelo Ravilet El mié, 03-05-2006 a las 16:42 +0200, Dony Pierre escribió: Hi all, I use SSH client and server on a Solaris 9 server, version is : Client : bash-2.05# pkginfo -l SUNWsshu PKGINST: SUNWsshu NAME: SSH Client and utilities, (Usr) CATEGORY: system ARCH: sparc VERSION: 11.9.0,REV=2002.04.06.15.27 BASEDIR: / VENDOR: Sun Microsystems, Inc. DESC: Secure Shell protocol Client and associated Utilities PSTAMP: leo20060203150929 INSTDATE: Mar 28 2006 15:17 HOTLINE: Please contact your local service provider STATUS: completely installed FILES: 11 installed pathnames 4 shared pathnames 4 directories 7 executables 4907 blocks used (approx) Server : bash-2.05# pkginfo -l SUNWsshdu PKGINST: SUNWsshdu NAME: SSH Server, (Usr) CATEGORY: system ARCH: sparc VERSION: 11.9.0,REV=2002.04.06.15.27 BASEDIR: / VENDOR: Sun Microsystems, Inc. DESC: Secure Shell protocol Server PSTAMP: leo20060206145323 INSTDATE: Mar 28 2006 15:16 HOTLINE: Please contact your local service provider STATUS: completely installed FILES:5 installed pathnames 3 shared pathnames 3 directories 2 executables 2147 blocks used (approx) We have a SSH return code problem when we use SSH in batch in Solaris. We haven't this problem on RedHat. bash-2.05$ cat a.sftp ls -l pwd get b.txt ls -l bash-2.05$ sftp -b a.sftp scnsys11 Connecting to scnsys11... Password: sftp ls -l drwxr-xr-x0 9108 10512 Apr 21 11:15 . drwxr-xr-x0 01 512 Apr 3 14:23 .. -rw---0 9108 10 2387 Apr 21 11:18 .bash_history -rw---0 9108 10240 Mar 28 16:19 .sh_history drwx--0 9108 10512 Mar 22 17:11 .ssh drwx--0 9108 10512 Mar 22 16:00 .ssh2 -rwxrwxrwx0 9108 10 26 Mar 29 15:22 a.sftp -rwxrwxrwx0 9108 10 0 Mar 28 15:28 a.txt -rw---0 9108 101021424 Mar 22 17:07 core sftp pwd Remote working directory: /export/home/huysego sftp get b.txt Couldn't stat remote file: No such file or directory File /export/home/huysego/b.txt not found. sftp ls -l drwxr-xr-x0 9108 10512 Apr 21 11:15 . drwxr-xr-x0 01 512 Apr 3 14:23 .. -rw---0 9108 10 2387 Apr 21 11:18 .bash_history -rw---0 9108 10240 Mar 28 16:19 .sh_history drwx--0 9108 10512 Mar 22 17:11 .ssh drwx--0 9108 10512 Mar 22 16:00 .ssh2 -rwxrwxrwx0 9108 10 26 Mar 29 15:22 a.sftp -rwxrwxrwx0 9108 10 0 Mar 28 15:28 a.txt -rw---0 9108 101021424 Mar 22 17:07 core sftp bash-2.05$ echo $? 0 ** As you can see in this example, sftp gives a rc = 0. If you try the same on RedHat, you will receive a rc not equal to 0. Does anybody have a solution to this problem ? Or another SSH client we can install in Solaris ?. Thanks. Regards. Pierre. - Visit our website! http://www.nbb.be DISCLAIMER: The content of this e-mail message should not be construed as binding on the part of the National Bank of Belgium (NBB) unless otherwise and previously stated. The opinions expressed in this message are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect NBB viewpoints, particularly when the content of this message, or part thereof, is private by nature or does not fall within the professional scope of its author.
Re: FW: SSH/SFTP rc problem in Solaris.
Hi I think that the situation is that the latest return code displayed was the one returned by the latest command executed, in this case the ls -l command. So I cannot see a problem in this particular case. HTH Marco Correnti ESACERT Marcelo Ravilet [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote on 04/05/2006 19:24:54: Hi dony, I see an error when the get command try get the file b.txt, because this file not exist!, what's the idea with this script? Regards, Marcelo Ravilet El mié, 03-05-2006 a las 16:42 +0200, Dony Pierre escribió: Hi all, I use SSH client and server on a Solaris 9 server, version is : Client : bash-2.05# pkginfo -l SUNWsshu PKGINST: SUNWsshu NAME: SSH Client and utilities, (Usr) CATEGORY: system ARCH: sparc VERSION: 11.9.0,REV=2002.04.06.15.27 BASEDIR: / VENDOR: Sun Microsystems, Inc. DESC: Secure Shell protocol Client and associated Utilities PSTAMP: leo20060203150929 INSTDATE: Mar 28 2006 15:17 HOTLINE: Please contact your local service provider STATUS: completely installed FILES: 11 installed pathnames 4 shared pathnames 4 directories 7 executables 4907 blocks used (approx) Server : bash-2.05# pkginfo -l SUNWsshdu PKGINST: SUNWsshdu NAME: SSH Server, (Usr) CATEGORY: system ARCH: sparc VERSION: 11.9.0,REV=2002.04.06.15.27 BASEDIR: / VENDOR: Sun Microsystems, Inc. DESC: Secure Shell protocol Server PSTAMP: leo20060206145323 INSTDATE: Mar 28 2006 15:16 HOTLINE: Please contact your local service provider STATUS: completely installed FILES:5 installed pathnames 3 shared pathnames 3 directories 2 executables 2147 blocks used (approx) We have a SSH return code problem when we use SSH in batch in Solaris. We haven't this problem on RedHat. bash-2.05$ cat a.sftp ls -l pwd get b.txt ls -l bash-2.05$ sftp -b a.sftp scnsys11 Connecting to scnsys11... Password: sftp ls -l drwxr-xr-x0 9108 10512 Apr 21 11:15 . drwxr-xr-x0 01 512 Apr 3 14:23 .. -rw---0 9108 10 2387 Apr 21 11:18 .bash_history -rw---0 9108 10240 Mar 28 16:19 .sh_history drwx--0 9108 10512 Mar 22 17:11 .ssh drwx--0 9108 10512 Mar 22 16:00 .ssh2 -rwxrwxrwx0 9108 10 26 Mar 29 15:22 a.sftp -rwxrwxrwx0 9108 10 0 Mar 28 15:28 a.txt -rw---0 9108 101021424 Mar 22 17:07 core sftp pwd Remote working directory: /export/home/huysego sftp get b.txt Couldn't stat remote file: No such file or directory File /export/home/huysego/b.txt not found. sftp ls -l drwxr-xr-x0 9108 10512 Apr 21 11:15 . drwxr-xr-x0 01 512 Apr 3 14:23 .. -rw---0 9108 10 2387 Apr 21 11:18 .bash_history -rw---0 9108 10240 Mar 28 16:19 .sh_history drwx--0 9108 10512 Mar 22 17:11 .ssh drwx--0 9108 10512 Mar 22 16:00 .ssh2 -rwxrwxrwx0 9108 10 26 Mar 29 15:22 a.sftp -rwxrwxrwx0 9108 10 0 Mar 28 15:28 a.txt -rw---0 9108 101021424 Mar 22 17:07 core sftp bash-2.05$ echo $? 0 ** As you can see in this example, sftp gives a rc = 0. If you try the same on RedHat, you will receive a rc not equal to 0. Does anybody have a solution to this problem ? Or another SSH client we can install in Solaris ?. Thanks. Regards. Pierre. - Visit our website! http://www.nbb.be DISCLAIMER: The content of this e-mail message should not be construed as binding on the part of the National Bank of Belgium (NBB) unless otherwise and previously stated. The opinions expressed in this message are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect NBB viewpoints, particularly when the content of this message, or part thereof, is private by nature or does not fall within the professional scope of its author.
