Bug#682100: gscan2pdf Recommends cuneiform which is in non-free

2012-07-20 Thread Ian Jackson
Ivo De Decker writes (Re: Bug#682100: gscan2pdf Recommends cuneiform which is in non-free): Gscan2pdf is used to scan documents and make pdf's from them. If you just want to have a scan of the image, it works perfectly without ocr. I often use it that way. I hadn't even noticed that ocr

Bug#682100: gscan2pdf Recommends cuneiform which is in non-free

2012-07-20 Thread Evgeni Golov
On Fri, Jul 20, 2012 at 12:42:30PM +0100, Ian Jackson wrote: Ivo De Decker writes (Re: Bug#682100: gscan2pdf Recommends cuneiform which is in non-free): Gscan2pdf is used to scan documents and make pdf's from them. If you just want to have a scan of the image, it works perfectly without

Bug#682100: gscan2pdf Recommends cuneiform which is in non-free

2012-07-20 Thread Ian Jackson
Evgeni Golov writes (Re: Bug#682100: gscan2pdf Recommends cuneiform which is in non-free): On Fri, Jul 20, 2012 at 12:42:30PM +0100, Ian Jackson wrote: In that case, the dependency relationship should be Suggests, not Recommends. In the words of the manual, Recommends is to be used when

Bug#682100: gscan2pdf Recommends cuneiform which is in non-free

2012-07-19 Thread Ian Jackson
Package: gscan2pdf Version: 1.0.4-3 Severity: serious I see here: http://packages.debian.org/sid/gscan2pdf this rec: cuneiform multi-language OCR system but http://packages.debian.org/sid/cuneiform says Package: cuneiform (1.1.0+dfsg-4 and others) [non-free] I think this is an RC

Bug#682100: gscan2pdf Recommends cuneiform which is in non-free

2012-07-19 Thread Evgeni Golov
Hi, if one should trust the package description OCR can be used to recognise text in the scans, and the output embedded in the PDF or DjVu. the OCR feature is purely optional and thus gscan2pdf should work fine w/o any ocr backend. Also, gscan2pdf Rcommends gocr, tesseract-ocr, cuneiform,

Bug#682100: gscan2pdf Recommends cuneiform which is in non-free

2012-07-19 Thread Ian Jackson
Evgeni Golov writes (Bug#682100: gscan2pdf Recommends cuneiform which is in non-free): the OCR feature is purely optional and thus gscan2pdf should work fine w/o any ocr backend. Thanks for responding. Also, gscan2pdf Rcommends gocr, tesseract-ocr, cuneiform, which all are OCR tools

Bug#682100: gscan2pdf Recommends cuneiform which is in non-free

2012-07-19 Thread Ivo De Decker
Ian, On Thu, Jul 19, 2012 at 05:39:18PM +0100, Ian Jackson wrote: How well does gscan2pdf work without ocr software ? Would you say it should be used with ocr software in all but unusual situations ? Gscan2pdf is used to scan documents and make pdf's from them. If you just want to have a scan

Bug#682100: gscan2pdf Recommends cuneiform which is in non-free

2012-07-19 Thread Jeffrey Ratcliffe
On 19 July 2012 17:53, Evgeni Golov evg...@golov.de wrote: From this I think cuneiform can be perfectly moved to Suggests. I hadn't realised that cuneiform was non-free. I don't understand why Recommends: gocr, tesseract-ocr, cuneiform is not ok. but Recommends: gocr | tesseract-ocr |

Bug#682100: gscan2pdf Recommends cuneiform which is in non-free

2012-07-19 Thread Ian Jackson
Jeffrey Ratcliffe writes (Bug#682100: gscan2pdf Recommends cuneiform which is in non-free): On 19 July 2012 17:53, Evgeni Golov evg...@golov.de wrote: From this I think cuneiform can be perfectly moved to Suggests. I hadn't realised that cuneiform was non-free. I don't understand why

Bug#682100: gscan2pdf Recommends cuneiform which is in non-free

2012-07-19 Thread Adam D. Barratt
On Thu, 2012-07-19 at 20:19 +0200, Jeffrey Ratcliffe wrote: I hadn't realised that cuneiform was non-free. I don't understand why Recommends: gocr, tesseract-ocr, cuneiform This says all three packages are recommended, so with installation of recommends turned on package managers will