Bug#575309: user-setup: Should stop adding first user to device access groups

2010-03-25 Thread Joey Hess
Frans Pop wrote: I disagree with this proposed change. IMO the default group assignments are in line with the purpose of the first user account. I have three reasons to feel otherwise: 1. IIRC, the reason for adding the initial user to groups has been to provide a good desktop experience.

Bug#575309: user-setup: Should stop adding first user to device access groups

2010-03-25 Thread Chris Bell
On Thu 25 Mar, Joey Hess wrote: Frans Pop wrote: I disagree with this proposed change. IMO the default group assignments are in line with the purpose of the first user account. I have three reasons to feel otherwise: 1. IIRC, the reason for adding the initial user to groups has been to

Bug#575309: user-setup: Should stop adding first user to device access groups

2010-03-24 Thread Petter Reinholdtsen
Package: user-setup Version: 1.28 Tags:patch In squeeze, the desktop uses consolekit and friends to grant access to devices for the user in front on the screen. This scale a lot better when there is a lot of users in LDAP or NIS that need to get access to the local devices on their own

Bug#575309: user-setup: Should stop adding first user to device access groups

2010-03-24 Thread Frans Pop
On Wednesday 24 March 2010, Petter Reinholdtsen wrote: The code in user-setup-apply to add the first user to all the groups in passwd/user-default-groups should no longer be needed. I believe it should be dropped for Squeeze, or at least the default groups used should be trimmed down to

Bug#575309: user-setup: Should stop adding first user to device access groups

2010-03-24 Thread Petter Reinholdtsen
[Frans Pop] What about (server) systems that don't have consolekit installed? Yes, what about them? If the local user to have special privileges, one should install the packages providing such privileges to the local user. What harm do the current group assignments do? After all, we're only

Bug#575309: user-setup: Should stop adding first user to device access groups

2010-03-24 Thread Frans Pop
On Wednesday 24 March 2010, Petter Reinholdtsen wrote: What about (server) systems that don't have consolekit installed? Yes, what about them? On such systems the first user would be left without expected default access to devices. If the local user to have special privileges, one should