Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-09 Thread martin f krafft
also sprach Russell Coker [EMAIL PROTECTED] [2007.01.08.2239 +0100]: Sure, there is a RAID superblock that can be used for such things. However doing so without a partition type is a little more risky. A common practice on PC hardware is to change the partition type to prevent the system

Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-09 Thread martin f krafft
also sprach Russell Coker [EMAIL PROTECTED] [2007.01.08.2236 +0100]: Where do I find this mdassemble? A grep of Contents-i386.gz gives: usr/bin/mdassembler devel/monodoc-base It's not yet packaged but part of the mdadm source package. mdassemble would

Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-09 Thread Goswin von Brederlow
Claus Fischer [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Suggestions: 1. Rescue mode needs MD devices Try grml. I found that much more helpfull in emergencies. 4. Netinstall image should have some packages I'm not sure on that ... but having grub, a kernel and a modules package would

Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-09 Thread Goswin von Brederlow
martin f krafft [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: also sprach Roberto C. Sanchez [EMAIL PROTECTED] [2007.01.07.0456 +0100]: Well, at the least it should scan for partitions marked as a RAID and prompt the user whether or not to start the set. Other than the partition type, there's no way to do this,

Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-09 Thread Claus Fischer
On Tue, Jan 09, 2007 at 09:11:57PM +0100, Goswin von Brederlow wrote: : 4. Netinstall image should have some packages : : I'm not sure on that ... but having grub, a : kernel and a modules package would have been : an immense help. : : They used to be on there. Are you sure you have

Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-09 Thread Goswin von Brederlow
Claus Fischer [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: On Tue, Jan 09, 2007 at 09:11:57PM +0100, Goswin von Brederlow wrote: : 4. Netinstall image should have some packages : : I'm not sure on that ... but having grub, a : kernel and a modules package would have been : an immense help. :

Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-08 Thread Peter Samuelson
[Claus Fischer] 9. cdrecord's miserable state is well known Like the majority of other Linux users, I wonder when $ burn_my_iso_to_cd iso-file /dev/cdrom will work as expected. Hmmm. $ wodim filename.iso works for most situations. But: 1) You must be root, or a member of

Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-08 Thread martin f krafft
also sprach Russell Coker [EMAIL PROTECTED] [2007.01.08.0007 +0100]: Is there any technical reason why busybox could not have such functionality? If not I'll file a bug report (and I'll write the code if I ever have spare time). Why busybox and not just mdassemble, which is a stripped version

Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-08 Thread Roberto C. Sanchez
On Mon, Jan 08, 2007 at 10:07:12AM +1100, Russell Coker wrote: It's not always possible on other architectures. What do you do on a platform that supports the BSD disk label and has no type number? Are there any platforms other than i386, AMD64, and IA64 that support the partition

Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-08 Thread Gunnar Wolf
Russell Coker dijo [Mon, Jan 08, 2007 at 10:07:12AM +1100]: Other than the partition type, there's no way to do this, and setting the partition type is not always desirable. It's not always possible on other architectures. What do you do on a platform that supports the BSD disk label

Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-08 Thread Claus Fischer
On Mon, Jan 08, 2007 at 03:26:21AM -0600, Peter Samuelson wrote: : : [Claus Fischer] : 9. cdrecord's miserable state is well known : : Like the majority of other Linux users, I wonder when : $ burn_my_iso_to_cd iso-file /dev/cdrom : will work as expected. : : Hmmm. : : $

Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-08 Thread Claus Fischer
Russel Coker spoke: : The rescue mode of the installer needs a step : to activate MD devices. Currently, only the plain : disk partitions are visible; that's no help. : : Sounds like a reasonable request. Filed a bug report? : : Note that it has to be an optional measure. I will,

Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-08 Thread Anthony DeRobertis
Alexey Feldgendler wrote: cp -avx --preserve=all 1/* 2 # rsync will do as well Of course, 1/* misses any dot-files in 1. -- To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] with a subject of unsubscribe. Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-08 Thread Russell Coker
On Tuesday 09 January 2007 00:36, Roberto C. Sanchez [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Are there any platforms other than i386, AMD64, and IA64 that support the partition type number? Not sure. Is there not some magic number associated with different partition types? I don't mean like you find on

Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-08 Thread Russell Coker
On Monday 08 January 2007 20:57, martin f krafft [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: also sprach Russell Coker [EMAIL PROTECTED] [2007.01.08.0007 +0100]: Is there any technical reason why busybox could not have such functionality? If not I'll file a bug report (and I'll write the code if I ever have

Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-07 Thread Russell Coker
On Sunday 07 January 2007 14:56, Roberto C. Sanchez [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The rescue mode of the installer needs a step to activate MD devices. Currently, only the plain disk partitions are visible; that's no help. Sounds like a reasonable request. Filed a bug report?

Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-07 Thread martin f krafft
also sprach Roberto C. Sanchez [EMAIL PROTECTED] [2007.01.07.0456 +0100]: Well, at the least it should scan for partitions marked as a RAID and prompt the user whether or not to start the set. Other than the partition type, there's no way to do this, and setting the partition type is not always

Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-07 Thread Kurt Roeckx
On Sat, Jan 06, 2007 at 10:56:33PM -0500, Roberto C. Sanchez wrote: On Sun, Jan 07, 2007 at 01:25:31PM +1100, Russell Coker wrote: On Saturday 06 January 2007 18:35, Claus Fischer [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: 1. Rescue mode needs MD devices The rescue mode of the installer needs a

Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-07 Thread Eduard Bloch
#include hallo.h * martin f krafft [Sun, Jan 07 2007, 12:15:59PM]: also sprach Roberto C. Sanchez [EMAIL PROTECTED] [2007.01.07.0456 +0100]: Well, at the least it should scan for partitions marked as a RAID and prompt the user whether or not to start the set. Other than the partition type,

Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-07 Thread martin f krafft
also sprach Eduard Bloch [EMAIL PROTECTED] [2007.01.07.1225 +0100]: Great to know that later but please think about the first user impression. This script needs to be documented well and/or be in the path with a sane name so it could easily be found. Patches welcome. :) -- Please do not send

Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-07 Thread Russell Coker
On Sunday 07 January 2007 22:15, martin f krafft [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: also sprach Roberto C. Sanchez [EMAIL PROTECTED] [2007.01.07.0456 +0100]: Well, at the least it should scan for partitions marked as a RAID and prompt the user whether or not to start the set. Other than the

Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-06 Thread Alexey Feldgendler
On Sat, 06 Jan 2007 08:35:59 +0100, Claus Fischer [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: 7. There needs to be a command to copy all data Between cp, tar, rsync friends there are dozens of variations how to copy over the files of a running system to another location, but none is perfect:

Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-06 Thread Adrian von Bidder
Yo! Having some rescue tools available in the installer medium is nice, but I usually prefer to use some full live CD system (Knoppix in my case) for the more involved rescue operations. (Especially since I usually download the businesscard ISO to install - and limiting what's being shipped

Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-06 Thread Russell Coker
On Saturday 06 January 2007 18:35, Claus Fischer [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: 1. Rescue mode needs MD devices The rescue mode of the installer needs a step to activate MD devices. Currently, only the plain disk partitions are visible; that's no help. Sounds like a reasonable request.

Re: Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-06 Thread Roberto C. Sanchez
On Sun, Jan 07, 2007 at 01:25:31PM +1100, Russell Coker wrote: On Saturday 06 January 2007 18:35, Claus Fischer [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: 1. Rescue mode needs MD devices The rescue mode of the installer needs a step to activate MD devices. Currently, only the plain disk

Etch Software RAID Upgrade Trouble Suggested Installer Improvements

2007-01-05 Thread Claus Fischer
Summary: Various mishaps when recovering a botched software RAID system. The rescue functionality of the installer should be improved. After a somewhat nightmarish (yet finally successful) upgrade of my main workhorse PC to Linux software RAID, I have decided to make this list of