Re: Software VS Hardware Raid

2002-02-01 Thread Jason Lim
There are some motherboards which have software RAID in the BIOS. This allows them to deal with that problem at boot time, and then the kernel does software RAID with the same mapping once it's loaded. Mmm... those boards use the Highpoint chip... thats not real good at anything ;-)

Re: Software VS Hardware Raid

2002-01-31 Thread Jose Alberto Guzman
Russell Coker wrote: On Wed, 30 Jan 2002 17:54, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: detected the drive, but during the part that lilo: is supposed to come up, nothing did. The disk kept grinding and grinding, and eventually asked for a floppy. I was hoping that the 2nd, working drive in the raid array

Re: Software VS Hardware Raid

2002-01-31 Thread Jason Lim
drive available. This requires that you do not boot with a failed disk in your system.' Which won't necessarily work with the most recent LILO because it relies on the BIOS detecting the disk as bad and skipping it (which may not happen). I think that may have been the problem I

Re: Software VS Hardware Raid

2002-01-31 Thread Russell Coker
On Fri, 1 Feb 2002 13:36, Jason Lim wrote: drive available. This requires that you do not boot with a failed disk in your system.' Which won't necessarily work with the most recent LILO because it relies on the BIOS detecting the disk as bad and skipping it (which may not

Re: Software VS Hardware Raid

2002-01-31 Thread Jason Lim
There are some motherboards which have software RAID in the BIOS. This allows them to deal with that problem at boot time, and then the kernel does software RAID with the same mapping once it's loaded. Mmm... those boards use the Highpoint chip... thats not real good at anything ;-)

Re: Software VS Hardware Raid

2002-01-29 Thread jose
On Mon, 28 Jan 2002, Jason Lim wrote: detected the drive, but during the part that lilo: is supposed to come up, nothing did. The disk kept grinding and grinding, and eventually asked for a floppy. I was hoping that the 2nd, working drive in the raid array would kick in any moment, but that

Re: Software VS Hardware Raid

2002-01-29 Thread Jason Lim
If the bad drive is put in by itself, after a while the disk is failed and it tries to boot by floppy. Does Lilo ever appear? or does the BIOS ask itself for a floppy disk? if LILO Loading Linux.. does not appear, then your HD is never going to make it as a root

Re: Software VS Hardware Raid

2002-01-28 Thread Jason Lim
Sincerely, - Original Message - From: Russell Coker [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Jason Lim [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Monday, January 28, 2002 2:26 PM Subject: Re: Software VS Hardware Raid On Mon, 28 Jan 2002 13:01, Jason Lim wrote: Case 1) I replaced one of the disks

Re: Software VS Hardware Raid

2002-01-28 Thread Jason Lim
My question: if this was hardware RAID 1... would this have happened? Would the hardware RAID controller recognise the problem, and only stop briefly, then try the second disk automatically and transparently? I believe hardware RAID would have worked transparently here. With

Re: Software VS Hardware Raid

2002-01-27 Thread Russell Coker
On Mon, 28 Jan 2002 13:01, Jason Lim wrote: Case 1) I replaced one of the disks with an old disk with bad blocks and strange [...] My question: if this was hardware RAID 1... would this have happened? Would the hardware RAID controller recognise the problem, and only stop briefly, then try