Re: [VOTE][SPIP] SPARK-21866 Image support in Apache Spark

[Tim Hunter]

Thank you everyone for the comments and the votes. We will follow up
shortly with a pull request.

On Wed, Sep 27, 2017 at 6:32 PM, Joseph Bradley <jos...@databricks.com>
wrote:

> This vote passes with 11 +1s (4 binding) and no +0s or -1s.
>
> +1:
> Sean Owen (binding)
> Holden Karau
> Denny Lee
> Reynold Xin (binding)
> Joseph Bradley (binding)
> Noman Khan
> Weichen Xu
> Yanbo Liang
> Dongjoon Hyun
> Matei Zaharia (binding)
> Vaquar Khan
>
> Thanks everyone!
> Joseph
>
> On Sat, Sep 23, 2017 at 4:23 PM, vaquar khan <vaquar.k...@gmail.com>
> wrote:
>
>> +1 looks good,
>>
>> Regards,
>> Vaquar khan
>>
>> On Sat, Sep 23, 2017 at 12:22 PM, Matei Zaharia <matei.zaha...@gmail.com>
>> wrote:
>>
>>> +1; we should consider something similar for multi-dimensional tensors
>>> too.
>>>
>>> Matei
>>>
>>> > On Sep 23, 2017, at 7:27 AM, Yanbo Liang <yblia...@gmail.com> wrote:
>>> >
>>> > +1
>>> >
>>> > On Sat, Sep 23, 2017 at 7:08 PM, Noman Khan <nomanbp...@live.com>
>>> wrote:
>>> > +1
>>> >
>>> > Regards
>>> > Noman
>>> > From: Denny Lee <denny.g@gmail.com>
>>> > Sent: Friday, September 22, 2017 2:59:33 AM
>>> > To: Apache Spark Dev; Sean Owen; Tim Hunter
>>> > Cc: Danil Kirsanov; Joseph Bradley; Reynold Xin; Sudarshan Sudarshan
>>> > Subject: Re: [VOTE][SPIP] SPARK-21866 Image support in Apache Spark
>>> >
>>> > +1
>>> >
>>> > On Thu, Sep 21, 2017 at 11:15 Sean Owen <so...@cloudera.com> wrote:
>>> > Am I right that this doesn't mean other packages would use this
>>> representation, but that they could?
>>> >
>>> > The representation looked fine to me w.r.t. what DL frameworks need.
>>> >
>>> > My previous comment was that this is actually quite lightweight. It's
>>> kind of like how I/O support is provided for CSV and JSON, so makes enough
>>> sense to add to Spark. It doesn't really preclude other solutions.
>>> >
>>> > For those reasons I think it's fine. +1
>>> >
>>> > On Thu, Sep 21, 2017 at 6:32 PM Tim Hunter <timhun...@databricks.com>
>>> wrote:
>>> > Hello community,
>>> >
>>> > I would like to call for a vote on SPARK-21866. It is a short proposal
>>> that has important applications for image processing and deep learning.
>>> Joseph Bradley has offered to be the shepherd.
>>> >
>>> > JIRA ticket: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-21866
>>> > PDF version: https://issues.apache.org/jira
>>> /secure/attachment/12884792/SPIP%20-%20Image%20support%20for
>>> %20Apache%20Spark%20V1.1.pdf
>>> >
>>> > Background and motivation
>>> > As Apache Spark is being used more and more in the industry, some new
>>> use cases are emerging for different data formats beyond the traditional
>>> SQL types or the numerical types (vectors and matrices). Deep Learning
>>> applications commonly deal with image processing. A number of projects add
>>> some Deep Learning capabilities to Spark (see list below), but they
>>> struggle to communicate with each other or with MLlib pipelines because
>>> there is no standard way to represent an image in Spark DataFrames. We
>>> propose to federate efforts for representing images in Spark by defining a
>>> representation that caters to the most common needs of users and library
>>> developers.
>>> > This SPIP proposes a specification to represent images in Spark
>>> DataFrames and Datasets (based on existing industrial standards), and an
>>> interface for loading sources of images. It is not meant to be a
>>> full-fledged image processing library, but rather the core description that
>>> other libraries and users can rely on. Several packages already offer
>>> various processing facilities for transforming images or doing more complex
>>> operations, and each has various design tradeoffs that make them better as
>>> standalone solutions.
>>> > This project is a joint collaboration between Microsoft and
>>> Databricks, which have been testing this design in two open source
>>> packages: MMLSpark and Deep Learning Pipelines.
>>> > The proposed image format is an in-memory, decompressed representation
>>> that targets low-level applications. It is significantly more liberal

Re: [VOTE][SPIP] SPARK-21866 Image support in Apache Spark

[Joseph Bradley]

This vote passes with 11 +1s (4 binding) and no +0s or -1s.

+1:
Sean Owen (binding)
Holden Karau
Denny Lee
Reynold Xin (binding)
Joseph Bradley (binding)
Noman Khan
Weichen Xu
Yanbo Liang
Dongjoon Hyun
Matei Zaharia (binding)
Vaquar Khan

Thanks everyone!
Joseph

On Sat, Sep 23, 2017 at 4:23 PM, vaquar khan <vaquar.k...@gmail.com> wrote:

> +1 looks good,
>
> Regards,
> Vaquar khan
>
> On Sat, Sep 23, 2017 at 12:22 PM, Matei Zaharia <matei.zaha...@gmail.com>
> wrote:
>
>> +1; we should consider something similar for multi-dimensional tensors
>> too.
>>
>> Matei
>>
>> > On Sep 23, 2017, at 7:27 AM, Yanbo Liang <yblia...@gmail.com> wrote:
>> >
>> > +1
>> >
>> > On Sat, Sep 23, 2017 at 7:08 PM, Noman Khan <nomanbp...@live.com>
>> wrote:
>> > +1
>> >
>> > Regards
>> > Noman
>> > From: Denny Lee <denny.g@gmail.com>
>> > Sent: Friday, September 22, 2017 2:59:33 AM
>> > To: Apache Spark Dev; Sean Owen; Tim Hunter
>> > Cc: Danil Kirsanov; Joseph Bradley; Reynold Xin; Sudarshan Sudarshan
>> > Subject: Re: [VOTE][SPIP] SPARK-21866 Image support in Apache Spark
>> >
>> > +1
>> >
>> > On Thu, Sep 21, 2017 at 11:15 Sean Owen <so...@cloudera.com> wrote:
>> > Am I right that this doesn't mean other packages would use this
>> representation, but that they could?
>> >
>> > The representation looked fine to me w.r.t. what DL frameworks need.
>> >
>> > My previous comment was that this is actually quite lightweight. It's
>> kind of like how I/O support is provided for CSV and JSON, so makes enough
>> sense to add to Spark. It doesn't really preclude other solutions.
>> >
>> > For those reasons I think it's fine. +1
>> >
>> > On Thu, Sep 21, 2017 at 6:32 PM Tim Hunter <timhun...@databricks.com>
>> wrote:
>> > Hello community,
>> >
>> > I would like to call for a vote on SPARK-21866. It is a short proposal
>> that has important applications for image processing and deep learning.
>> Joseph Bradley has offered to be the shepherd.
>> >
>> > JIRA ticket: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-21866
>> > PDF version: https://issues.apache.org/jira/secure/attachment/12884792/
>> SPIP%20-%20Image%20support%20for%20Apache%20Spark%20V1.1.pdf
>> >
>> > Background and motivation
>> > As Apache Spark is being used more and more in the industry, some new
>> use cases are emerging for different data formats beyond the traditional
>> SQL types or the numerical types (vectors and matrices). Deep Learning
>> applications commonly deal with image processing. A number of projects add
>> some Deep Learning capabilities to Spark (see list below), but they
>> struggle to communicate with each other or with MLlib pipelines because
>> there is no standard way to represent an image in Spark DataFrames. We
>> propose to federate efforts for representing images in Spark by defining a
>> representation that caters to the most common needs of users and library
>> developers.
>> > This SPIP proposes a specification to represent images in Spark
>> DataFrames and Datasets (based on existing industrial standards), and an
>> interface for loading sources of images. It is not meant to be a
>> full-fledged image processing library, but rather the core description that
>> other libraries and users can rely on. Several packages already offer
>> various processing facilities for transforming images or doing more complex
>> operations, and each has various design tradeoffs that make them better as
>> standalone solutions.
>> > This project is a joint collaboration between Microsoft and Databricks,
>> which have been testing this design in two open source packages: MMLSpark
>> and Deep Learning Pipelines.
>> > The proposed image format is an in-memory, decompressed representation
>> that targets low-level applications. It is significantly more liberal in
>> memory usage than compressed image representations such as JPEG, PNG, etc.,
>> but it allows easy communication with popular image processing libraries
>> and has no decoding overhead.
>> > Targets users and personas:
>> > Data scientists, data engineers, library developers.
>> > The following libraries define primitives for loading and representing
>> images, and will gain from a common interchange format (in alphabetical
>> order):
>> >   • BigDL
>> >   • DeepLearning4J
>> >   • Deep Learning

Re: [VOTE][SPIP] SPARK-21866 Image support in Apache Spark

[vaquar khan]

+1 looks good,

Regards,
Vaquar khan

On Sat, Sep 23, 2017 at 12:22 PM, Matei Zaharia <matei.zaha...@gmail.com>
wrote:

> +1; we should consider something similar for multi-dimensional tensors too.
>
> Matei
>
> > On Sep 23, 2017, at 7:27 AM, Yanbo Liang <yblia...@gmail.com> wrote:
> >
> > +1
> >
> > On Sat, Sep 23, 2017 at 7:08 PM, Noman Khan <nomanbp...@live.com> wrote:
> > +1
> >
> > Regards
> > Noman
> > From: Denny Lee <denny.g@gmail.com>
> > Sent: Friday, September 22, 2017 2:59:33 AM
> > To: Apache Spark Dev; Sean Owen; Tim Hunter
> > Cc: Danil Kirsanov; Joseph Bradley; Reynold Xin; Sudarshan Sudarshan
> > Subject: Re: [VOTE][SPIP] SPARK-21866 Image support in Apache Spark
> >
> > +1
> >
> > On Thu, Sep 21, 2017 at 11:15 Sean Owen <so...@cloudera.com> wrote:
> > Am I right that this doesn't mean other packages would use this
> representation, but that they could?
> >
> > The representation looked fine to me w.r.t. what DL frameworks need.
> >
> > My previous comment was that this is actually quite lightweight. It's
> kind of like how I/O support is provided for CSV and JSON, so makes enough
> sense to add to Spark. It doesn't really preclude other solutions.
> >
> > For those reasons I think it's fine. +1
> >
> > On Thu, Sep 21, 2017 at 6:32 PM Tim Hunter <timhun...@databricks.com>
> wrote:
> > Hello community,
> >
> > I would like to call for a vote on SPARK-21866. It is a short proposal
> that has important applications for image processing and deep learning.
> Joseph Bradley has offered to be the shepherd.
> >
> > JIRA ticket: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-21866
> > PDF version: https://issues.apache.org/jira/secure/attachment/
> 12884792/SPIP%20-%20Image%20support%20for%20Apache%20Spark%20V1.1.pdf
> >
> > Background and motivation
> > As Apache Spark is being used more and more in the industry, some new
> use cases are emerging for different data formats beyond the traditional
> SQL types or the numerical types (vectors and matrices). Deep Learning
> applications commonly deal with image processing. A number of projects add
> some Deep Learning capabilities to Spark (see list below), but they
> struggle to communicate with each other or with MLlib pipelines because
> there is no standard way to represent an image in Spark DataFrames. We
> propose to federate efforts for representing images in Spark by defining a
> representation that caters to the most common needs of users and library
> developers.
> > This SPIP proposes a specification to represent images in Spark
> DataFrames and Datasets (based on existing industrial standards), and an
> interface for loading sources of images. It is not meant to be a
> full-fledged image processing library, but rather the core description that
> other libraries and users can rely on. Several packages already offer
> various processing facilities for transforming images or doing more complex
> operations, and each has various design tradeoffs that make them better as
> standalone solutions.
> > This project is a joint collaboration between Microsoft and Databricks,
> which have been testing this design in two open source packages: MMLSpark
> and Deep Learning Pipelines.
> > The proposed image format is an in-memory, decompressed representation
> that targets low-level applications. It is significantly more liberal in
> memory usage than compressed image representations such as JPEG, PNG, etc.,
> but it allows easy communication with popular image processing libraries
> and has no decoding overhead.
> > Targets users and personas:
> > Data scientists, data engineers, library developers.
> > The following libraries define primitives for loading and representing
> images, and will gain from a common interchange format (in alphabetical
> order):
> >   • BigDL
> >   • DeepLearning4J
> >   • Deep Learning Pipelines
> >   • MMLSpark
> >   • TensorFlow (Spark connector)
> >   • TensorFlowOnSpark
> >   • TensorFrames
> >   • Thunder
> > Goals:
> >   • Simple representation of images in Spark DataFrames, based on
> pre-existing industrial standards (OpenCV)
> >   • This format should eventually allow the development of
> high-performance integration points with image processing libraries such as
> libOpenCV, Google TensorFlow, CNTK, and other C libraries.
> >   • The reader should be able to read popular formats of images from
> distributed sources.
> > Non-Goals:
> > Images are a versatile medium and en

Re: [VOTE][SPIP] SPARK-21866 Image support in Apache Spark

[Matei Zaharia]

+1; we should consider something similar for multi-dimensional tensors too.

Matei

> On Sep 23, 2017, at 7:27 AM, Yanbo Liang <yblia...@gmail.com> wrote:
> 
> +1
> 
> On Sat, Sep 23, 2017 at 7:08 PM, Noman Khan <nomanbp...@live.com> wrote:
> +1 
> 
> Regards 
> Noman 
> From: Denny Lee <denny.g@gmail.com>
> Sent: Friday, September 22, 2017 2:59:33 AM
> To: Apache Spark Dev; Sean Owen; Tim Hunter
> Cc: Danil Kirsanov; Joseph Bradley; Reynold Xin; Sudarshan Sudarshan
> Subject: Re: [VOTE][SPIP] SPARK-21866 Image support in Apache Spark
>  
> +1 
> 
> On Thu, Sep 21, 2017 at 11:15 Sean Owen <so...@cloudera.com> wrote:
> Am I right that this doesn't mean other packages would use this 
> representation, but that they could?
> 
> The representation looked fine to me w.r.t. what DL frameworks need.
> 
> My previous comment was that this is actually quite lightweight. It's kind of 
> like how I/O support is provided for CSV and JSON, so makes enough sense to 
> add to Spark. It doesn't really preclude other solutions.
> 
> For those reasons I think it's fine. +1
> 
> On Thu, Sep 21, 2017 at 6:32 PM Tim Hunter <timhun...@databricks.com> wrote:
> Hello community,
> 
> I would like to call for a vote on SPARK-21866. It is a short proposal that 
> has important applications for image processing and deep learning. Joseph 
> Bradley has offered to be the shepherd.
> 
> JIRA ticket: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-21866
> PDF version: 
> https://issues.apache.org/jira/secure/attachment/12884792/SPIP%20-%20Image%20support%20for%20Apache%20Spark%20V1.1.pdf
> 
> Background and motivation
> As Apache Spark is being used more and more in the industry, some new use 
> cases are emerging for different data formats beyond the traditional SQL 
> types or the numerical types (vectors and matrices). Deep Learning 
> applications commonly deal with image processing. A number of projects add 
> some Deep Learning capabilities to Spark (see list below), but they struggle 
> to communicate with each other or with MLlib pipelines because there is no 
> standard way to represent an image in Spark DataFrames. We propose to 
> federate efforts for representing images in Spark by defining a 
> representation that caters to the most common needs of users and library 
> developers.
> This SPIP proposes a specification to represent images in Spark DataFrames 
> and Datasets (based on existing industrial standards), and an interface for 
> loading sources of images. It is not meant to be a full-fledged image 
> processing library, but rather the core description that other libraries and 
> users can rely on. Several packages already offer various processing 
> facilities for transforming images or doing more complex operations, and each 
> has various design tradeoffs that make them better as standalone solutions.
> This project is a joint collaboration between Microsoft and Databricks, which 
> have been testing this design in two open source packages: MMLSpark and Deep 
> Learning Pipelines.
> The proposed image format is an in-memory, decompressed representation that 
> targets low-level applications. It is significantly more liberal in memory 
> usage than compressed image representations such as JPEG, PNG, etc., but it 
> allows easy communication with popular image processing libraries and has no 
> decoding overhead.
> Targets users and personas:
> Data scientists, data engineers, library developers.
> The following libraries define primitives for loading and representing 
> images, and will gain from a common interchange format (in alphabetical 
> order):
>   • BigDL
>   • DeepLearning4J
>   • Deep Learning Pipelines
>   • MMLSpark
>   • TensorFlow (Spark connector)
>   • TensorFlowOnSpark
>   • TensorFrames
>   • Thunder
> Goals:
>   • Simple representation of images in Spark DataFrames, based on 
> pre-existing industrial standards (OpenCV)
>   • This format should eventually allow the development of 
> high-performance integration points with image processing libraries such as 
> libOpenCV, Google TensorFlow, CNTK, and other C libraries.
>   • The reader should be able to read popular formats of images from 
> distributed sources.
> Non-Goals:
> Images are a versatile medium and encompass a very wide range of formats and 
> representations. This SPIP explicitly aims at the most common use case in the 
> industry currently: multi-channel matrices of binary, int32, int64, float or 
> double data that can fit comfortably in the heap of the JVM:
>   • the total size of an image should be restricted to less than 2GB 
> (roughly)
>   • the meaning o

Re: [VOTE][SPIP] SPARK-21866 Image support in Apache Spark

[Yanbo Liang]

+1

On Sat, Sep 23, 2017 at 7:08 PM, Noman Khan <nomanbp...@live.com> wrote:

> +1
>
> Regards
> Noman
> --
> *From:* Denny Lee <denny.g@gmail.com>
> *Sent:* Friday, September 22, 2017 2:59:33 AM
> *To:* Apache Spark Dev; Sean Owen; Tim Hunter
> *Cc:* Danil Kirsanov; Joseph Bradley; Reynold Xin; Sudarshan Sudarshan
> *Subject:* Re: [VOTE][SPIP] SPARK-21866 Image support in Apache Spark
>
> +1
>
> On Thu, Sep 21, 2017 at 11:15 Sean Owen <so...@cloudera.com> wrote:
>
>> Am I right that this doesn't mean other packages would use this
>> representation, but that they could?
>>
>> The representation looked fine to me w.r.t. what DL frameworks need.
>>
>> My previous comment was that this is actually quite lightweight. It's
>> kind of like how I/O support is provided for CSV and JSON, so makes enough
>> sense to add to Spark. It doesn't really preclude other solutions.
>>
>> For those reasons I think it's fine. +1
>>
>> On Thu, Sep 21, 2017 at 6:32 PM Tim Hunter <timhun...@databricks.com>
>> wrote:
>>
>>> Hello community,
>>>
>>> I would like to call for a vote on SPARK-21866. It is a short proposal
>>> that has important applications for image processing and deep learning.
>>> Joseph Bradley has offered to be the shepherd.
>>>
>>> JIRA ticket: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-21866
>>> PDF version: https://issues.apache.org/jira/secure/attachment/12884792/
>>> SPIP%20-%20Image%20support%20for%20Apache%20Spark%20V1.1.pdf
>>>
>>> Background and motivation
>>>
>>> As Apache Spark is being used more and more in the industry, some new
>>> use cases are emerging for different data formats beyond the traditional
>>> SQL types or the numerical types (vectors and matrices). Deep Learning
>>> applications commonly deal with image processing. A number of projects add
>>> some Deep Learning capabilities to Spark (see list below), but they
>>> struggle to communicate with each other or with MLlib pipelines because
>>> there is no standard way to represent an image in Spark DataFrames. We
>>> propose to federate efforts for representing images in Spark by defining a
>>> representation that caters to the most common needs of users and library
>>> developers.
>>>
>>> This SPIP proposes a specification to represent images in Spark
>>> DataFrames and Datasets (based on existing industrial standards), and an
>>> interface for loading sources of images. It is not meant to be a
>>> full-fledged image processing library, but rather the core description that
>>> other libraries and users can rely on. Several packages already offer
>>> various processing facilities for transforming images or doing more complex
>>> operations, and each has various design tradeoffs that make them better as
>>> standalone solutions.
>>>
>>> This project is a joint collaboration between Microsoft and Databricks,
>>> which have been testing this design in two open source packages: MMLSpark
>>> and Deep Learning Pipelines.
>>>
>>> The proposed image format is an in-memory, decompressed representation
>>> that targets low-level applications. It is significantly more liberal in
>>> memory usage than compressed image representations such as JPEG, PNG, etc.,
>>> but it allows easy communication with popular image processing libraries
>>> and has no decoding overhead.
>>> Targets users and personas:
>>>
>>> Data scientists, data engineers, library developers.
>>> The following libraries define primitives for loading and representing
>>> images, and will gain from a common interchange format (in alphabetical
>>> order):
>>>
>>>- BigDL
>>>- DeepLearning4J
>>>- Deep Learning Pipelines
>>>- MMLSpark
>>>- TensorFlow (Spark connector)
>>>- TensorFlowOnSpark
>>>- TensorFrames
>>>- Thunder
>>>
>>> Goals:
>>>
>>>- Simple representation of images in Spark DataFrames, based on
>>>pre-existing industrial standards (OpenCV)
>>>- This format should eventually allow the development of
>>>high-performance integration points with image processing libraries such 
>>> as
>>>libOpenCV, Google TensorFlow, CNTK, and other C libraries.
>>>- The reader should be able to read popular formats of images from
>>>distributed sources.
>>&g

Re: [VOTE][SPIP] SPARK-21866 Image support in Apache Spark

[Noman Khan]

+1

Regards
Noman

From: Denny Lee <denny.g@gmail.com>
Sent: Friday, September 22, 2017 2:59:33 AM
To: Apache Spark Dev; Sean Owen; Tim Hunter
Cc: Danil Kirsanov; Joseph Bradley; Reynold Xin; Sudarshan Sudarshan
Subject: Re: [VOTE][SPIP] SPARK-21866 Image support in Apache Spark

+1

On Thu, Sep 21, 2017 at 11:15 Sean Owen 
<so...@cloudera.com<mailto:so...@cloudera.com>> wrote:
Am I right that this doesn't mean other packages would use this representation, 
but that they could?

The representation looked fine to me w.r.t. what DL frameworks need.

My previous comment was that this is actually quite lightweight. It's kind of 
like how I/O support is provided for CSV and JSON, so makes enough sense to add 
to Spark. It doesn't really preclude other solutions.

For those reasons I think it's fine. +1

On Thu, Sep 21, 2017 at 6:32 PM Tim Hunter 
<timhun...@databricks.com<mailto:timhun...@databricks.com>> wrote:
Hello community,

I would like to call for a vote on SPARK-21866. It is a short proposal that has 
important applications for image processing and deep learning. Joseph Bradley 
has offered to be the shepherd.

JIRA ticket: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-21866
PDF version: 
https://issues.apache.org/jira/secure/attachment/12884792/SPIP%20-%20Image%20support%20for%20Apache%20Spark%20V1.1.pdf

Background and motivation

As Apache Spark is being used more and more in the industry, some new use cases 
are emerging for different data formats beyond the traditional SQL types or the 
numerical types (vectors and matrices). Deep Learning applications commonly 
deal with image processing. A number of projects add some Deep Learning 
capabilities to Spark (see list below), but they struggle to communicate with 
each other or with MLlib pipelines because there is no standard way to 
represent an image in Spark DataFrames. We propose to federate efforts for 
representing images in Spark by defining a representation that caters to the 
most common needs of users and library developers.

This SPIP proposes a specification to represent images in Spark DataFrames and 
Datasets (based on existing industrial standards), and an interface for loading 
sources of images. It is not meant to be a full-fledged image processing 
library, but rather the core description that other libraries and users can 
rely on. Several packages already offer various processing facilities for 
transforming images or doing more complex operations, and each has various 
design tradeoffs that make them better as standalone solutions.

This project is a joint collaboration between Microsoft and Databricks, which 
have been testing this design in two open source packages: MMLSpark and Deep 
Learning Pipelines.

The proposed image format is an in-memory, decompressed representation that 
targets low-level applications. It is significantly more liberal in memory 
usage than compressed image representations such as JPEG, PNG, etc., but it 
allows easy communication with popular image processing libraries and has no 
decoding overhead.

Targets users and personas:

Data scientists, data engineers, library developers.
The following libraries define primitives for loading and representing images, 
and will gain from a common interchange format (in alphabetical order):

  *   BigDL
  *   DeepLearning4J
  *   Deep Learning Pipelines
  *   MMLSpark
  *   TensorFlow (Spark connector)
  *   TensorFlowOnSpark
  *   TensorFrames
  *   Thunder

Goals:

  *   Simple representation of images in Spark DataFrames, based on 
pre-existing industrial standards (OpenCV)
  *   This format should eventually allow the development of high-performance 
integration points with image processing libraries such as libOpenCV, Google 
TensorFlow, CNTK, and other C libraries.
  *   The reader should be able to read popular formats of images from 
distributed sources.

Non-Goals:

Images are a versatile medium and encompass a very wide range of formats and 
representations. This SPIP explicitly aims at the most common use case in the 
industry currently: multi-channel matrices of binary, int32, int64, float or 
double data that can fit comfortably in the heap of the JVM:

  *   the total size of an image should be restricted to less than 2GB (roughly)
  *   the meaning of color channels is application-specific and is not mandated 
by the standard (in line with the OpenCV standard)
  *   specialized formats used in meteorology, the medical field, etc. are not 
supported
  *   this format is specialized to images and does not attempt to solve the 
more general problem of representing n-dimensional tensors in Spark

Proposed API changes

We propose to add a new package in the package structure, under the MLlib 
project:
org.apache.spark.image

Data format

We propose to add the following structure:

imageSchema = StructType([

  *   StructField("mode", StringType(), False),
 

Re: [VOTE][SPIP] SPARK-21866 Image support in Apache Spark

[Denny Lee]

+1

On Thu, Sep 21, 2017 at 11:15 Sean Owen  wrote:

> Am I right that this doesn't mean other packages would use this
> representation, but that they could?
>
> The representation looked fine to me w.r.t. what DL frameworks need.
>
> My previous comment was that this is actually quite lightweight. It's kind
> of like how I/O support is provided for CSV and JSON, so makes enough sense
> to add to Spark. It doesn't really preclude other solutions.
>
> For those reasons I think it's fine. +1
>
> On Thu, Sep 21, 2017 at 6:32 PM Tim Hunter 
> wrote:
>
>> Hello community,
>>
>> I would like to call for a vote on SPARK-21866. It is a short proposal
>> that has important applications for image processing and deep learning.
>> Joseph Bradley has offered to be the shepherd.
>>
>> JIRA ticket: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-21866
>> PDF version: https://issues.apache.org/jira/secure/attachment/12884792/
>> SPIP%20-%20Image%20support%20for%20Apache%20Spark%20V1.1.pdf
>>
>> Background and motivation
>>
>> As Apache Spark is being used more and more in the industry, some new use
>> cases are emerging for different data formats beyond the traditional SQL
>> types or the numerical types (vectors and matrices). Deep Learning
>> applications commonly deal with image processing. A number of projects add
>> some Deep Learning capabilities to Spark (see list below), but they
>> struggle to communicate with each other or with MLlib pipelines because
>> there is no standard way to represent an image in Spark DataFrames. We
>> propose to federate efforts for representing images in Spark by defining a
>> representation that caters to the most common needs of users and library
>> developers.
>>
>> This SPIP proposes a specification to represent images in Spark
>> DataFrames and Datasets (based on existing industrial standards), and an
>> interface for loading sources of images. It is not meant to be a
>> full-fledged image processing library, but rather the core description that
>> other libraries and users can rely on. Several packages already offer
>> various processing facilities for transforming images or doing more complex
>> operations, and each has various design tradeoffs that make them better as
>> standalone solutions.
>>
>> This project is a joint collaboration between Microsoft and Databricks,
>> which have been testing this design in two open source packages: MMLSpark
>> and Deep Learning Pipelines.
>>
>> The proposed image format is an in-memory, decompressed representation
>> that targets low-level applications. It is significantly more liberal in
>> memory usage than compressed image representations such as JPEG, PNG, etc.,
>> but it allows easy communication with popular image processing libraries
>> and has no decoding overhead.
>> Targets users and personas:
>>
>> Data scientists, data engineers, library developers.
>> The following libraries define primitives for loading and representing
>> images, and will gain from a common interchange format (in alphabetical
>> order):
>>
>>- BigDL
>>- DeepLearning4J
>>- Deep Learning Pipelines
>>- MMLSpark
>>- TensorFlow (Spark connector)
>>- TensorFlowOnSpark
>>- TensorFrames
>>- Thunder
>>
>> Goals:
>>
>>- Simple representation of images in Spark DataFrames, based on
>>pre-existing industrial standards (OpenCV)
>>- This format should eventually allow the development of
>>high-performance integration points with image processing libraries such 
>> as
>>libOpenCV, Google TensorFlow, CNTK, and other C libraries.
>>- The reader should be able to read popular formats of images from
>>distributed sources.
>>
>> Non-Goals:
>>
>> Images are a versatile medium and encompass a very wide range of formats
>> and representations. This SPIP explicitly aims at the most common use
>> case in the industry currently: multi-channel matrices of binary, int32,
>> int64, float or double data that can fit comfortably in the heap of the JVM:
>>
>>- the total size of an image should be restricted to less than 2GB
>>(roughly)
>>- the meaning of color channels is application-specific and is not
>>mandated by the standard (in line with the OpenCV standard)
>>- specialized formats used in meteorology, the medical field, etc.
>>are not supported
>>- this format is specialized to images and does not attempt to solve
>>the more general problem of representing n-dimensional tensors in Spark
>>
>> Proposed API changes
>>
>> We propose to add a new package in the package structure, under the MLlib
>> project:
>> org.apache.spark.image
>> Data format
>>
>> We propose to add the following structure:
>>
>> imageSchema = StructType([
>>
>>- StructField("mode", StringType(), False),
>>   - The exact representation of the data.
>>   - The values are described in the following OpenCV convention.
>>   Basically, the type has both "depth" and "number 

Re: [VOTE][SPIP] SPARK-21866 Image support in Apache Spark

[Sean Owen]

Am I right that this doesn't mean other packages would use this
representation, but that they could?

The representation looked fine to me w.r.t. what DL frameworks need.

My previous comment was that this is actually quite lightweight. It's kind
of like how I/O support is provided for CSV and JSON, so makes enough sense
to add to Spark. It doesn't really preclude other solutions.

For those reasons I think it's fine. +1

On Thu, Sep 21, 2017 at 6:32 PM Tim Hunter  wrote:

> Hello community,
>
> I would like to call for a vote on SPARK-21866. It is a short proposal
> that has important applications for image processing and deep learning.
> Joseph Bradley has offered to be the shepherd.
>
> JIRA ticket: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-21866
> PDF version: https://issues.apache.org/jira/secure/attachment/12884792/
> SPIP%20-%20Image%20support%20for%20Apache%20Spark%20V1.1.pdf
>
> Background and motivation
>
> As Apache Spark is being used more and more in the industry, some new use
> cases are emerging for different data formats beyond the traditional SQL
> types or the numerical types (vectors and matrices). Deep Learning
> applications commonly deal with image processing. A number of projects add
> some Deep Learning capabilities to Spark (see list below), but they
> struggle to communicate with each other or with MLlib pipelines because
> there is no standard way to represent an image in Spark DataFrames. We
> propose to federate efforts for representing images in Spark by defining a
> representation that caters to the most common needs of users and library
> developers.
>
> This SPIP proposes a specification to represent images in Spark
> DataFrames and Datasets (based on existing industrial standards), and an
> interface for loading sources of images. It is not meant to be a
> full-fledged image processing library, but rather the core description that
> other libraries and users can rely on. Several packages already offer
> various processing facilities for transforming images or doing more complex
> operations, and each has various design tradeoffs that make them better as
> standalone solutions.
>
> This project is a joint collaboration between Microsoft and Databricks,
> which have been testing this design in two open source packages: MMLSpark
> and Deep Learning Pipelines.
>
> The proposed image format is an in-memory, decompressed representation
> that targets low-level applications. It is significantly more liberal in
> memory usage than compressed image representations such as JPEG, PNG, etc.,
> but it allows easy communication with popular image processing libraries
> and has no decoding overhead.
> Targets users and personas:
>
> Data scientists, data engineers, library developers.
> The following libraries define primitives for loading and representing
> images, and will gain from a common interchange format (in alphabetical
> order):
>
>- BigDL
>- DeepLearning4J
>- Deep Learning Pipelines
>- MMLSpark
>- TensorFlow (Spark connector)
>- TensorFlowOnSpark
>- TensorFrames
>- Thunder
>
> Goals:
>
>- Simple representation of images in Spark DataFrames, based on
>pre-existing industrial standards (OpenCV)
>- This format should eventually allow the development of
>high-performance integration points with image processing libraries such as
>libOpenCV, Google TensorFlow, CNTK, and other C libraries.
>- The reader should be able to read popular formats of images from
>distributed sources.
>
> Non-Goals:
>
> Images are a versatile medium and encompass a very wide range of formats
> and representations. This SPIP explicitly aims at the most common use
> case in the industry currently: multi-channel matrices of binary, int32,
> int64, float or double data that can fit comfortably in the heap of the JVM:
>
>- the total size of an image should be restricted to less than 2GB
>(roughly)
>- the meaning of color channels is application-specific and is not
>mandated by the standard (in line with the OpenCV standard)
>- specialized formats used in meteorology, the medical field, etc. are
>not supported
>- this format is specialized to images and does not attempt to solve
>the more general problem of representing n-dimensional tensors in Spark
>
> Proposed API changes
>
> We propose to add a new package in the package structure, under the MLlib
> project:
> org.apache.spark.image
> Data format
>
> We propose to add the following structure:
>
> imageSchema = StructType([
>
>- StructField("mode", StringType(), False),
>   - The exact representation of the data.
>   - The values are described in the following OpenCV convention.
>   Basically, the type has both "depth" and "number of channels" info: in
>   particular, type "CV_8UC3" means "3 channel unsigned bytes". BGRA format
>   would be CV_8UC4 (value 32 in the table) with the channel order 
> specified
>   

[VOTE][SPIP] SPARK-21866 Image support in Apache Spark

[Tim Hunter]

Hello community,

I would like to call for a vote on SPARK-21866. It is a short proposal that
has important applications for image processing and deep learning. Joseph
Bradley has offered to be the shepherd.

JIRA ticket: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-21866
PDF version: https://issues.apache.org/jira/secure/attachment/12884792/SPIP
%20-%20Image%20support%20for%20Apache%20Spark%20V1.1.pdf

Background and motivation

As Apache Spark is being used more and more in the industry, some new use
cases are emerging for different data formats beyond the traditional SQL
types or the numerical types (vectors and matrices). Deep Learning
applications commonly deal with image processing. A number of projects add
some Deep Learning capabilities to Spark (see list below), but they
struggle to communicate with each other or with MLlib pipelines because
there is no standard way to represent an image in Spark DataFrames. We
propose to federate efforts for representing images in Spark by defining a
representation that caters to the most common needs of users and library
developers.

This SPIP proposes a specification to represent images in Spark DataFrames
and Datasets (based on existing industrial standards), and an interface for
loading sources of images. It is not meant to be a full-fledged image
processing library, but rather the core description that other libraries
and users can rely on. Several packages already offer various processing
facilities for transforming images or doing more complex operations, and
each has various design tradeoffs that make them better as standalone
solutions.

This project is a joint collaboration between Microsoft and Databricks,
which have been testing this design in two open source packages: MMLSpark
and Deep Learning Pipelines.

The proposed image format is an in-memory, decompressed representation that
targets low-level applications. It is significantly more liberal in memory
usage than compressed image representations such as JPEG, PNG, etc., but it
allows easy communication with popular image processing libraries and has
no decoding overhead.
Targets users and personas:

Data scientists, data engineers, library developers.
The following libraries define primitives for loading and representing
images, and will gain from a common interchange format (in alphabetical
order):

   - BigDL
   - DeepLearning4J
   - Deep Learning Pipelines
   - MMLSpark
   - TensorFlow (Spark connector)
   - TensorFlowOnSpark
   - TensorFrames
   - Thunder

Goals:

   - Simple representation of images in Spark DataFrames, based on
   pre-existing industrial standards (OpenCV)
   - This format should eventually allow the development of
   high-performance integration points with image processing libraries such as
   libOpenCV, Google TensorFlow, CNTK, and other C libraries.
   - The reader should be able to read popular formats of images from
   distributed sources.

Non-Goals:

Images are a versatile medium and encompass a very wide range of formats
and representations. This SPIP explicitly aims at the most common use case
in the industry currently: multi-channel matrices of binary, int32, int64,
float or double data that can fit comfortably in the heap of the JVM:

   - the total size of an image should be restricted to less than 2GB
   (roughly)
   - the meaning of color channels is application-specific and is not
   mandated by the standard (in line with the OpenCV standard)
   - specialized formats used in meteorology, the medical field, etc. are
   not supported
   - this format is specialized to images and does not attempt to solve the
   more general problem of representing n-dimensional tensors in Spark

Proposed API changes

We propose to add a new package in the package structure, under the MLlib
project:
org.apache.spark.image
Data format

We propose to add the following structure:

imageSchema = StructType([

   - StructField("mode", StringType(), False),
  - The exact representation of the data.
  - The values are described in the following OpenCV convention.
  Basically, the type has both "depth" and "number of channels" info: in
  particular, type "CV_8UC3" means "3 channel unsigned bytes". BGRA format
  would be CV_8UC4 (value 32 in the table) with the channel order specified
  by convention.
  - The exact channel ordering and meaning of each channel is dictated
  by convention. By default, the order is RGB (3 channels) and BGRA (4
  channels).
  If the image failed to load, the value is the empty string "".


   - StructField("origin", StringType(), True),
  - Some information about the origin of the image. The content of this
  is application-specific.
  - When the image is loaded from files, users should expect to find
  the file name in this field.


   - StructField("height", IntegerType(), False),
  - the height of the image, pixels
  - If the image fails to load, the value is -1.


   - StructField("width",