Re: [dmarc-discuss] Get failure reports without actually rejecting messages?

2017-07-12 Thread Steven M Jones via dmarc-discuss
Hi Jonathan, > After further research, I think this is because failure reports aren't > actually generated for p=none, i.e., they're only generated for p=reject. There is no such linkage. I see failure reports for domains that publish "p=none" all the time. However (unfortunately) I don't get

Re: [dmarc-discuss] Get failure reports without actually rejecting messages?

2017-07-12 Thread Roland Turner via dmarc-discuss
Hi Jonathan, Your thesis is incorrect: there is no connection between your specified policy and whether you'll receive failure reports. Very few receivers are willing to send failure reports so, in general, you won't receive them. There are some situations in which they are made available

[dmarc-discuss] Get failure reports without actually rejecting messages?

2017-07-11 Thread Jonathan Kamens via dmarc-discuss
We've recently started using DMARC for our domain, and we're doing our best to get everything passing before we switch from p=none to p=reject. Unfortunately, the information we're getting from the aggregate reports that various domains are sending us is not always sufficient for us to figure out