Re: Securely delete files...

2008-08-20 Thread Vlad SATtva Miller
Robert J. Hansen (20.08.2008 09:12): Bhushan Jain wrote: I wanted to know how could the file be deleted securely using PGP? Assuming you meant GnuPG, the answer is 'no'. Assuming you meant PGP, the answer is 'maybe'. PGP provides a secure deletion tool, but as far as I know there has

Re: Securely delete files...

2008-08-20 Thread Robert J. Hansen
Vlad SATtva Miller wrote: It employs Gutmann's methodology on secure file erasure, so there *is* a study of its effectiveness. No one in the private sector has ever claimed to be able to recover data overwritten even once. Think about it this way. The next two people you see today, one of

Re: gpg-agent, ssh-add crypto card keys

2008-08-20 Thread Werner Koch
On Tue, 19 Aug 2008 12:01, [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: Do anyone have any suggestions on how to proceed? Check out whether scdaemon is working, example: $ gpg-connect-agent scd serialno S SERIALNO D27600012401010100010347 0 OK Youy probably get an error here. To further

Re: Securely delete files...

2008-08-20 Thread Werner Koch
On Wed, 20 Aug 2008 02:32, [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: However, as you are asking this question of the GnuPG list, I suspect you mean to ask about GnuPG. GnuPG does not have a secure delete feature. Let me add that one reason for not providing a secure deletetion feature is that gpg is Unix tool

failure to install

2008-08-20 Thread Ravi Uday
Hi, Unable to install gnupg-1.4.9 .. Making install in zlib make-3.79.1-p3a[1]: Entering directory `/users/ruday/gnupg-1.4.9/zlib' make-3.79.1-p3a[2]: Entering directory `/users/ruday/gnupg-1.4.9/zlib' make-3.79.1-p3a[2]: Nothing to be done for `install-exec-am'. make-3.79.1-p3a[2]: Nothing to

Re: [GnuPG-users] failure to install

2008-08-20 Thread Kiss Gabor (Bitman)
1. You are not root enough (no problem is /usr/local/bin writable by you) Ooops! I mean no problem if /usr/local/bin is writable by you Gabor ___ Gnupg-users mailing list Gnupg-users@gnupg.org http://lists.gnupg.org/mailman/listinfo/gnupg-users

Re: Securely delete files...

2008-08-20 Thread David Shaw
On Aug 20, 2008, at 3:04 AM, Vlad SATtva Miller wrote: Robert J. Hansen (20.08.2008 09:12): Bhushan Jain wrote: I wanted to know how could the file be deleted securely using PGP? Assuming you meant GnuPG, the answer is 'no'. Assuming you meant PGP, the answer is 'maybe'. PGP provides a

Re: Securely delete files...

2008-08-20 Thread David Shaw
On Aug 20, 2008, at 4:08 AM, Werner Koch wrote: On Wed, 20 Aug 2008 02:32, [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: However, as you are asking this question of the GnuPG list, I suspect you mean to ask about GnuPG. GnuPG does not have a secure delete feature. Let me add that one reason for not providing a

Re: Securely delete files...

2008-08-20 Thread kunalvshah
http://www.fileshredder.org/ File Shredder works perfectly great for this purpose. -- Original message -- From: Atom Smasher [EMAIL PROTECTED] On Wed, 20 Aug 2008, Bhushan Jain wrote: I wanted to know how could the file be deleted securely using PGP?

Re: Securely delete files...

2008-08-20 Thread kunalvshah
To check the effectiveness, according to DoD anything that is not wiped with algorithm DoD 5220.22M has potential to be recovered. File shredder works well with DoD algorithm and higher. Also it is free. If you are looking to wipe a disk,you can use DiskNuke. Both are sourceforge.net projects.

Re: Securely delete files... [going further off topic]

2008-08-20 Thread Mark H. Wood
On Wed, Aug 20, 2008 at 09:11:16AM -0500, Robert J. Hansen wrote: If anyone on the list is an EE or a physics geek looking for a good paper, it might be interesting to explore using the Curie Point as a data erasure technique. For a lot of the exotic magnetic materials used in modern hard

Re: Securely delete files...

2008-08-20 Thread Werner Koch
On Wed, 20 Aug 2008 16:45, [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: If you are looking to wipe a disk,you can use DiskNuke. Both are sourceforge.net projects. You cannot clear a modern drive using external software! It doesn't matter what validated software algorithm you use. Drives may reorder sectors on

Re: Securely delete files...

2008-08-20 Thread Chris Walters
Werner Koch wrote: You cannot clear a modern drive using external software! It doesn't matter what validated software algorithm you use. Drives may reorder sectors on the fly, they use read and write caches and do all kind of tricks to squeeze out more performance. There are even solid

Re: Securely delete files...

2008-08-20 Thread John W. Moore III
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA512 Chris Walters wrote: Werner Koch wrote: That won't be an easy puzzle to solve. I hate to tell you this, but the F.B.I. Computer Forensics Laboratory has successfully recovered data from a drive, where the platters were shot multiple times

Re: Securely delete files...

2008-08-20 Thread Chris Walters
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA512 John W. Moore III wrote: Chris Walters wrote: Werner Koch wrote: That won't be an easy puzzle to solve. I hate to tell you this, but the F.B.I. Computer Forensics Laboratory has successfully recovered data from a drive, where the platters

Re: Securely delete files...

2008-08-20 Thread Michel Messerschmidt
On Wed, Aug 20, 2008 at 04:21:04PM -0400, John W. Moore III wrote: I believe that We are all agreed that physical destruction of the HD is the only truly effective means of ensuring Data cannot be recovered. There is also the possibility to use encryption for *all* data on a harddisk. If the

Re: Securely delete files...

2008-08-20 Thread Chris Walters
Mark H. Wood wrote: On Wed, Aug 20, 2008 at 04:00:19PM -0400, Chris Walters wrote: I hate to tell you this, but the F.B.I. Computer Forensics Laboratory has successfully recovered data from a drive, where the platters were shot multiple times with a shotgun. The only sure way to make sure

Re: Securely delete files...

2008-08-20 Thread Mark H. Wood
On Wed, Aug 20, 2008 at 04:00:19PM -0400, Chris Walters wrote: I hate to tell you this, but the F.B.I. Computer Forensics Laboratory has successfully recovered data from a drive, where the platters were shot multiple times with a shotgun. The only sure way to make sure no one can recover

Re: Securely delete files...

2008-08-20 Thread Atom Smasher
On Wed, 20 Aug 2008, Chris Walters wrote: I hate to tell you this, but the F.B.I. Computer Forensics Laboratory has successfully recovered data from a drive, where the platters were shot multiple times with a shotgun. == that wouldn't surprise me, but is there a reference for it?

Re: Securely delete files...

2008-08-20 Thread Atom Smasher
On Wed, 20 Aug 2008, Michel Messerschmidt wrote: There is also the possibility to use encryption for *all* data on a harddisk. If the key is stored somewhere else (e.g. in your mind or on another disk), this may prevent data recovery on a similar level. === encrypted disks, and

Re: Securely delete files... [going further off topic]

2008-08-20 Thread Robert J. Hansen
Mark H. Wood wrote: Hmmm. You'd have to ensure that every point within the coating on every platter reaches the critical temperature (perhaps for a minimum amount of time?). That sounds too uncertain when certain destruction is required. The idea is that if, say, the CP of the

Re: Securely delete files...

2008-08-20 Thread Faramir
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA256 Werner Koch escribió: On Wed, 20 Aug 2008 16:45, [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: If you are looking to wipe a disk,you can use DiskNuke. Both are sourceforge.net projects. You cannot clear a modern drive using external software! It doesn't

Re: Securely delete files...

2008-08-20 Thread Robert J. Hansen
Chris Walters wrote: I hate to tell you this, but the F.B.I. Computer Forensics Laboratory has successfully recovered data from a drive, where the platters were shot multiple times with a shotgun. I have a friend who works in Interesting Places who tells me they once successfully put

Re: Securely delete files...

2008-08-20 Thread Robert J. Hansen
Faramir wrote: lets say I just want to avoid recovery software like get data back being able to recover a file. Is there a reliable way to do it without going to extreme solutions? No. I have seen advices about using ccleaner, fileshredder, erase57, and other tools like those For the most

Re: Securely delete files...

2008-08-20 Thread Chris Walters
Michel Messerschmidt wrote: There is also the possibility to use encryption for *all* data on a harddisk. If the key is stored somewhere else (e.g. in your mind or on another disk), this may prevent data recovery on a similar level. Let's not confuse a *key* and a *passphrase*. This

Re: Securely delete files...

2008-08-20 Thread Kunal Shah
Robert J. Hansen wrote: Faramir wrote: lets say I just want to avoid recovery software like get data back being able to recover a file. Is there a reliable way to do it without going to extreme solutions? No. I have seen advices about using ccleaner, fileshredder, erase57, and other

Re: Securely delete files...

2008-08-20 Thread Robert J. Hansen
Kunal Shah wrote: I wouldn't argue about methods discussed here to destroy the disk. However one consideration is, what data we are talking about. In my CISSP course, I was not taught to *destroy* data or protect it. I was just taught to make it so difficult for hacker to access it so that

Re: Securely delete files...

2008-08-20 Thread Sven Radde
Hi! Am Mittwoch, den 20.08.2008, 21:09 -0400 schrieb Faramir: The idea is to make deleted files (not whole drives) unrecoverable to commercial recovery software. The german IT-magazine c't did such a test quite some time ago (in 2003, IIRC) and found that a data recovery firm was unable to

Re: Securely delete files...

2008-08-20 Thread Chris Walters
Robert J. Hansen wrote: I can only speak for myself here, but I strongly suspect Werner, David, Mark and everyone else who's been chiming in will agree -- we are not talking about total destruction of hard drives as something you should want to do. We're talking about total destruction of