[Bug 1959702] Re: Regression: ip6 ndp broken, host bridge doesn't add vlan guest entry to mdb

2022-02-10 Thread Harry Coin
It looks to be 'an interesting mystery' we're chasing. This system is in production, so the results below are with the whole 'snooping engine' off as without it the whole thing dies. As such, I don't think the contents of the fdb and mdb tables mean much. The setups below are unchanged, they

[Bug 1959702] Re: Regression: ip6 ndp broken, host bridge doesn't add vlan guest entry to mdb

2022-02-09 Thread Jay Vosburgh
Harry, I'm still working to reproduce this, without success. I have set the .autoconf sysctl to 0 (which controls creation of local addresses in response to received Router Advertisements), as well as setting .addr_gen_mode to 1 (to disable SLAAC (fe80::) addresses). In any

[Bug 1959702] Re: Regression: ip6 ndp broken, host bridge doesn't add vlan guest entry to mdb

2022-02-09 Thread Harry Coin
P.S. The reason this is a security issue is-- there is now an address on the host that the guest also 'knows' and it sits on the bridge giving access to all the other guests on the bridge. Most admins will not 'just know' they need rules to block fe80 traffic generated by host interfaces--

[Bug 1959702] Re: Regression: ip6 ndp broken, host bridge doesn't add vlan guest entry to mdb

2022-02-09 Thread Harry Coin
I need to repeat: in sysctl.d put this line in a file, then reboot, then your test setup will show the failure: net.ipv6.conf.all.autoconf = 0 Otherwise, in your test setup the tables are populated, then you delete the addresses, but the L3/4 code engaged by even a little time with the fe80:...

[Bug 1959702] Re: Regression: ip6 ndp broken, host bridge doesn't add vlan guest entry to mdb

2022-02-08 Thread Harry Coin
** Changed in: linux (Ubuntu) Status: Incomplete => Confirmed -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to the bug report. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1959702 Title: Regression: ip6 ndp broken, host bridge doesn't add vlan

Re: [Bug 1959702] Re: Regression: ip6 ndp broken, host bridge doesn't add vlan guest entry to mdb

2022-02-05 Thread Harry Coin
On 2/5/22 18:59, Jay Vosburgh wrote: > Harry, > > I am attempting to reproduce the behavior you describe, but have been > unable to do so. Could you clarify some of the configuration specifics, > as follows: > > Starting with step 2, > > "2. On the host, create a bridge and vlan with two ports,

Re: [Bug 1959702] Re: Regression: ip6 ndp broken, host bridge doesn't add vlan guest entry to mdb

2022-02-05 Thread Harry Coin
On 2/5/22 18:59, Jay Vosburgh wrote: > Harry, > > I am attempting to reproduce the behavior you describe, but have been > unable to do so. Could you clarify some of the configuration specifics, > as follows: > > Starting with step 2, > > "2. On the host, create a bridge and vlan with two ports,

[Bug 1959702] Re: Regression: ip6 ndp broken, host bridge doesn't add vlan guest entry to mdb

2022-02-05 Thread Jay Vosburgh
Harry, I am attempting to reproduce the behavior you describe, but have been unable to do so. Could you clarify some of the configuration specifics, as follows: Starting with step 2, "2. On the host, create a bridge and vlan with two ports, each with the chosen vlan as PVID and egress

Re: [Bug 1959702] Re: Regression: ip6 ndp broken, host bridge doesn't add vlan guest entry to mdb

2022-02-01 Thread Harry Coin
Yup, those failures were to do with an old radeon chipset on an ancient server. On 2/1/22 17:33, Seth Arnold wrote: > Sounds good, thanks: > > [0.00] Linux version 5.11.0-49-generic (buildd@lcy02-amd64-054) > (gcc (Ubuntu 10.3.0-1ubuntu1) 10.3.0, GNU ld (GNU Binutils for Ubuntu) >

[Bug 1959702] Re: Regression: ip6 ndp broken, host bridge doesn't add vlan guest entry to mdb

2022-02-01 Thread Seth Arnold
Sounds good, thanks: [0.00] Linux version 5.11.0-49-generic (buildd@lcy02-amd64-054) (gcc (Ubuntu 10.3.0-1ubuntu1) 10.3.0, GNU ld (GNU Binutils for Ubuntu) 2.36.1) #55-Ubuntu SMP Wed Jan 12 17:36:34 UTC 2022 (Ubuntu 5.11.0-49.55-generic 5.11.22) btw, there were a bunch of memory