Re: [whatwg] Image maps: should we drop a coords=?

2005-09-01 Thread fantasai
Ian Hickson wrote: On Mon, 11 Apr 2005, Anne van Kesteren wrote: Yup, it is indeed nice; if image maps had been designed that way from the start it would make sense. But it's not _that_ much nicer than area, which we could define as allowing: object data=foo usemap=#foo map id=foo

Re: [whatwg] Image maps: should we drop a coords=?

2005-04-14 Thread Matthew Raymond
Ian Hickson wrote: On Mon, 11 Apr 2005, Anne van Kesteren wrote: Ian Hickson wrote: Anyone want us to keep a coords=? The reason I especially liked it was: object data=foo usemap=#foo map id=foo ul lia coords=../a ... Yup, it is indeed nice; if image maps had been designed that way

[whatwg] Image maps: should we drop a coords=?

2005-04-11 Thread Ian Hickson
There are fours ways of doing image maps in HTML4: Server-side with form submit: form ... input type=image ... /form Server-side with hyperlink: a ... img ismap ... /a Client-side with area: img usemap=#foo (or object usemap=#foo/object) map id=foo ... area coords=...

Re: [whatwg] Image maps: should we drop a coords=?

2005-04-11 Thread Anne van Kesteren
Ian Hickson wrote: Anyone want us to keep a coords=? The reason I especially liked it was: object data=foo usemap=#foo map id=foo ul lia coords=../a ... ... but I never really used it for something as it wasn't supported by IE... By the way, will it be deprecated, not mentioned

Re: [whatwg] Image maps: should we drop a coords=?

2005-04-11 Thread fantasai
Ian Hickson wrote: Client-side with a (doesn't work in WinIE6, works in Moz, Opera): img usemap=#foo (or object usemap=#foo/object) map id=foo ... a coords=... .../a /map I couldn't find any uses of a coords=. (Data based on a sample of over 600,000 randomly chosen sites.) I'd

Re: [whatwg] Image maps: should we drop a coords=?

2005-04-11 Thread Ian Hickson
On Mon, 11 Apr 2005, Anne van Kesteren wrote: Ian Hickson wrote: Anyone want us to keep a coords=? The reason I especially liked it was: object data=foo usemap=#foo map id=foo ul lia coords=../a ... Yup, it is indeed nice; if image maps had been designed that way

Re: [whatwg] Image maps: should we drop a coords=?

2005-04-11 Thread Ian Hickson
On Mon, 11 Apr 2005, fantasai wrote: Anyone want us to keep a coords=? If Moz and Opera support it, then it already passes CR criteria. Yeah, but so what? It's not used, it's redundant with another (more widely implemented, not must worse) feature, and it makes the spec more complicated.

Re: [whatwg] Image maps: should we drop a coords=?

2005-04-11 Thread Lachlan Hunt
Ian Hickson wrote: Client-side with a (doesn't work in WinIE6, works in Moz, Opera): img usemap=#foo (or object usemap=#foo/object) map id=foo ... a coords=... .../a /map I've never seen that used at all either, most likely because it doesn't work in IE and because every single