Please change javadoc as well if you remove final (describe in short
the use case). In general I'm very very careful in opening things up.
Juergen
On 11/10/06, Eelco Hillenius [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Yeah. Erik, I see your point for the general case, but Alberto's case
- which I have myself
In my case, I have created a TextField component, that is a panel that
contains internally a TextField wicket component. Now, if I add the
method addToField, the user will have two methods:
TextField.add(IBehavior behavior)
TextField.addToField(IBehavior behavior)
I think that this case
Yeah. Erik, I see your point for the general case, but Alberto's case
- which I have myself sometimes too - is that you only use a panel
because you have to, but you want the user to view your component as
one of it's embedded elements (in his case the TextField). I think
that's a valid case.
So,
Hi,
now I have this solution, but I don't like it for you reasons:
- Now I have two methods to add a Behavior: add(IBehavior) and
addToField(IBehavior), and for the users can be confuse.
- I want to have a transparent component. The user doesn't have to know
that he is working with a panel.
I could definitively live with removing final there. And maybe some
other methods too.
Anyone against removing final from add(IBehavior)?
Eelco
On 11/9/06, Alberto Bueno [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Hi,
now I have this solution, but I don't like it for you reasons:
- Now I have two methods to
I am definitely /not/ against removing final, but it is not going to
work (not in general that is).
Alberto's defense is that the user thinks he is working with a field,
while in reality he is working with a panel. I assume that Alberto is
using a panel because he wants some extra
Hi,
I want to overwrite the add(IBehavior) method of the component, but this
method is final.
I want to use the same idea of AlternateParent when we add a new component.
I have a panel, and I want to add a behavior in the panel, but the
behavior is used in a field
component that is in the
Why don't you write in your panel: void addToField(Behavior b) {...}?
There is no need to corrupt the meaning of Wicket methods ;)
Regards,
Erik.
Alberto Bueno schreef:
Hi,
I want to overwrite the add(IBehavior) method of the component, but this
method is final.
I want to use the
