Hey, first of all, thanks George and Alex for pushing the work forward!
On Sun, Oct 30, 2016 at 12:59 PM, George Kiagiadakis <gkia...@tolabaki.gr> wrote: > Hi all, > > <snip> > > Moving to Github > ================ > This is some great news! I realize it's too late now so I'll merely mention this perhaps for future reference, but there's also Gitlab, where for example the Accounts SSO project is hosted. Gitlab is more free-as-in-freedom software friendly and regularly releases open source version of their server. I feel like a free software project fits better with Gitlab rather than Github, but I can also see why Github is the obvious choice. On the issue of Bugzilla vs Github for patches - well, Bugzilla is a tool meant for bugs, not really for patch reviews, especially with git workflows. Github is much much more better equipped for code reviews and accepting patches. I mean reviews like https://bugs.freedesktop.org/show_bug.cgi?id=34416 require so much manual work, copy paste and context switching while forcing the patch to be contained in narrow column (I have a 27" screen, I want to use all of my screen). I find this terrible for reviews compared to, say, Github reviews, which also allows to maintain clean comments threads (in addition to clean commit history). I as a developer want to do as little work as possible when it comes to posting patches but also reviewing patches. I'm reading the diff, I want to say something about the line I'm reading right now, I click it, I write my thoughts, I press a button, all done. The bugzilla that's hosted on FDO is in no way "great system for patch review", sorry. I'd vote for having issues on Github too. It keeps the project together, doesn't require two very different accounts (Github and Bugzilla) to work on one project and finally, Github issues are integrated out-of-the-box with the Github reviews. Bugzilla as it stands doesn't really offer much over Github's issues, so imo no reason to not keep the project all under single roof. It should be where the development happens. Wiki - as Gergely mentioned, Github pages may be a very good alternative. From there it could even link to individual project's wikis. Cheers -- Martin Klapetek | KDE Developer
_______________________________________________ telepathy mailing list telepathy@lists.freedesktop.org https://lists.freedesktop.org/mailman/listinfo/telepathy