not sure if any posted this yet.. but this is from Apple: ---
Greetings from the iTunes Podcasting Team: Apple TV is here, and podcasts are making a big move into the living room. We want all of them to look as good as possible, so we have three video formatting recommendations for you. Also note that we have just posted a revised and expanded technical spec. Finally, the Apple Worldwide Developers Conference is coming up. There's a major focus on developers of content in addition to developers of software. Recommendations for Formatting Video Podcasts 1. If you're encoding your video podcast at 320x240, please increase the resolution to either 640x480 or 640x360 (depending on the aspect ratio of your source files). Why? Because video podcasts at this resolution look great on Apple TV and still port to video iPods. Lower resolution podcasts might also work on both platforms, but they don't look nearly as good on a widescreen TV. As always, make sure to test any encoding changes you make to ensure device compatibility. QuickTime 7.1's "Export to iPod" function will ensure that a video file is encoded at a width of 640 and is iPod-compatible. 2. It's best not to create two different podcast feeds for different resolutions. By doing so, you dilute the popularity of your podcast and reduce exposure in our charts. It's better to have one feed high in the charts than two that are lower. 3. If your source files are 16:9, stick with that aspect ratio. Don't add letterboxing to make them 4:3. By doing so, you prevent the video from expanding to fill a 16:9 widescreen TV and instead end up with black space on all four sides. Also, your original source files should be at least 640 pixels wide. Of course these are just recommendations. We understand that there are good reasons for 320x240 (bandwidth bills) and 720p (looks fantastic). Do whatever makes the most sense for your show. For more information on formatting video, see the recently updated spec: http://www.apple.com/itunes/store/podcaststechspecs.html To see a sample of excellent podcasts that also look great with Apple TV, check out the Apple TV Podcast Showcase. WWDC June 11 - 15, San Francisco, CA The Apple Worldwide Developers Conference (WWDC07) has a whole session track dedicated to Content and Media developers, designers, information architects, graphic designers and web producers. You'll learn how to implement best practices to harness digital content for delivery to the Web, applications and devices such as the iPod or Apple TV. Whether you're creating next- generation rich-media portals or leveraging the latest AJAX toolkits to develop hybrid/Web integrated OS X applications, the Content and Media track provides the latest information on how to build modern, platform-optimized experiences for Mac OS X Leopard. WWDC07 is your opportunity to connect with Apple engineers, get a firsthand look at the latest technologies and spend a week getting the information you won't find anywhere else. http://developer.apple.com/wwdc/ Best regards, The iTunes Podcasting Team -- --- In videoblogging@yahoogroups.com, andrew michael baron <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > The only reason NOT to go with separate files, in my opinion, is > based on ranking in the charts. For instance, if you have 2 or three > dif quicktime feeds, it starts to divide your itunes audiences and > then you dont get reported on any charts. There is some discovery > loss for people who browse itunes. > > Im new to TVs myself, but aren't most HD TV's optimized for wide- > screen viewing? And isn't the iphone widescreen as well? So why 3:4 > letterbox that much of the screen real-estate? It would have to be a > pretty selfish reason, no? > > And if someone is going to watch on just an iPod, Id rather spend the > selfishness on saving the bandwidth because the increase in quality > doesn't seem substantial enough for a small ipod screen unless an > audience member is a rare audiophile type or collector. > > Everyone is different, though it seems logical and not unfamiliar to > provide multiple feeds and file formats. Format options seem to be > expanding, not narrowing. > > Drew > > p.s. It would be interesting to ask Scott S. about this: I recall the > publicly distributed info about the possibility of a single cross > platform file format (i.e. a 640x480 file for ipod, tv and "some > other devise") that came out just before the iphone was introduced. > Interestingly enough, I heard from David Pogue - based on his > interview with Jobs - that Apple used tactics to fool, hide and > divert info from their employees and their partners in order to keep > the iPhone secret up until the last minute. Thus, the inference that > there would be no widescreen anything was made. Kinda of a far > fetched casual proposition as to why people are stuck with 3:4 a > consequence but you never know :) >
