Dear friend Put a proposal that the land will be given in partnership with mittals on profitsharing proportional to the land for all times to come. It is only valid economics of the project regards S P Sinha SHRMS
On Fri, 30 May 2008 Braja Mishra wrote : >Dear All Concerned , > > > >Can anybody work out an economics of putting a mega steel plant either in >Orissa or Jharkhand , by POSCO or Mittal ? That will be right campaign for a >good cause. It should cover : > > > >1. What is the wealth expected to be created for whom and at what cost >? > >2. What is the amount of sweet water , which is otherwise getting >scarce day by day for human habitation, these plants are going to utilize >and the amount of pollution they will cause to water bodies and air thereby >causing immense damage to the environment , health of human and animals, >land surrounding the area thereby damaging the soil fertility and affecting >the livelihoods of millions ? > >3. How much of forest resources will be damaged in mining operation , >again causing immense damage to flora and fauna/ ecology/bio-diversity of >forest resources and affecting livelihoods of millions > >4. How many employment it will generate and how much money the >employees shall ultimately be paid ? > >5. Our experience says, putting mega industries in the backward >regions of India has been able to perpetuate poverty in those areas. It does >not need not require any explanation. > >6. Industries including those in Public Sector have been fooling the >people by doing some charity in peripheries , by putting up a primary >school, a tube well, bla.bla.bla and claim that they contribute >substantially to the development of the area !! Is this development ? > >7. For example hundreds of sponge iron factories have come up in >Sundargarh District of Orissa in recent times, flouting all pollution >control norms, damaging the whole environment affecting millions in human >and animal habitat ! > > > >Let this message go to common people whose livelihoods are threatened. They >have to make a choice between bad and worse. > > > >BS > > > > > > > >-----Original Message----- > From: [email protected] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On >Behalf Of Gladson Dungdung >Sent: Friday, May 30, 2008 1:49 PM >To: [email protected] >Subject: [ =>> Jharkhand <<= ] Tribals fear displacement by ArcelorMittal > > > >Tribals fear displacement by ArcelorMittal > > > >Company is likely to complete its detailed project report for its proposed > >plant by December > > > >Over 1000 people took out a march demanding protection of land from > >multi-national companies > > > >'Those displaced for setting up public sector units during last 40 years > >are yet to be compensated' > > > >Ranchi: After South Korean steel major POSCO's proposed greenfield project > >in Orissa, the one by the world's biggest steelmaker ArcellorMittal in > >Jharkhand has met with resistance from residents at the proposed site of the > >plant who fear displacement. > > > >Residents of Rania, Karra, Torpa and Kamdara blocks in Jharkhand's Khunti > >and Gumla districts on Thursday pledged resistance against acquisition of > >tribal land by L.N. Mittal-promoted steel conglomerate. > > > >Over 1000 people under the banner of 'Adivasi-Moolvasi Rakhsa Manch' took > >out a march from Sanik Theatre to Raj Bhavan here demanding protection of > >tribal land from multi-national companies. > > > >'Not an inch of land' > > > >"We will not give an inch of land to ArcelorMittal which is set to acquire > >our land as it would displace about one lakh people in the four blocks," > >Manch convenor Dayamani Barla told newsmen. > > > >The demonstrators submitted a memorandum to the staff at the Raj Bhavan gate > >as Governor Syed Sibtey Razi was out of the State, Barla said. > > > >ArcelorMittal is scheduled to complete its detailed project report for its > >proposed 12 mt steel plant by December this year and has already finished > >its survey at Kamdra (Gumla district) and Torpa (Khunti district) for its > >proposed plant. > > > >Citing the example of displacement of people during the setting up of Heavy > >Engineering Corporation, Bokaro Steel Plant and other public sectors over 40 > >years, the memorandum said they were allegedly still to get the > >compensation. It also warned against flouting the Chotanagpur Tenancy Act > >which protects tribal land. > > > >Bonded labourers > > > >The tribals demanded that no project that displaced people should be allowed > >as land acquisition would force the agriculture land-owners to migrate and > >work as bonded labourers elsewhere. > > > >"Migration is inevitable as the Jharkhand government has not yet come out > >with any rehabilitation and resettlement policy. The tribals have been > >exploited whenever a project had been set up," claimed Barla. > > > >ArcelorMittal had recently organised a workshop here that delved into the > >dynamics of social transformation that accompanies industrialisation. -- PTI > > > >http://www.hindu.com/2008/05/30/stories/2008053051670300.htm ><http://www.hindu.com/2008/05/30/stories/2008053051670300.htm> > > > >-- > > > > > > Join Jharkhand Social Network <http://jharkhand.ning.com> > ><http://egroups.com/list/Jharkhand> > > > > > > > > > > >
