unsubscribe ---------- ----- Original Message ----- From: "Yoshie Furuhashi" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Wednesday, November 13, 2002 7:48 PM Subject: [L-I] The Left and the Military: Leaping the Chasm (by Stan Goff)
Military Matters The Left and the Military: Leaping the Chasm by Stan Goff _The Freedom Road Socialist Organization is pleased to post the first of what will be an irregular series of columns by Stan Goff on military affairs. This obviously has considerable importance for everyone trying to build opposition as the Bush administration's generic "war on terror" escalates into a planned invasion and occupation of Iraq. Stan's expertise is derived from over two decades in Special Forces in the US military, from Viet Nam to Haiti. He is the author of Hideous Dream, a penetrating first-hand account of the 1994 US intervention in Haiti which contains rich lessons about the operation of US imperialism, the culture of the armed forces, questions of military doctrine, and the resistance of the Haitian people. It is available from Soft Skull Press [@ <http://www.softskull.com/cgi-bin/SoftCart.100.exe/store/goff/hideous_dream. html?L+scstore+zdeb4357+1037241284>]._ When I wrote Hideous Dream (Soft Skull Press, 2000), like every writer I think, I had a reader in mind. I have been justly accused of being somewhat arcane in that memoir. The reason is, my reader was the only person I really knew at the time: a soldier. I went back, of course, at the behest of my editor, to insert explanations, but he let me keep the basic idiom intact. Soldier to soldier. I still hope soldiers read it. It is intended, at least to some degree, to validate their experience. Since my retirement from the Army (February 1, 1996), I have divested myself of all personal relations inside the military. My friends and associates are now almost exclusively political activists who we might perfunctorily refer to as "the left." In 2001, after a book signing in Chapel Hill, NC, I had the pleasure of meeting anthropologist Dr. Catherine Lutz, who was in the final stages of publishing her own book about the military, Homefront, A Military City and the American 20th Century (Beacon Press, 2001). The book is her study of Fayetteville, NC, the city adjacent to Fort Bragg. It is a well-written, very readable, and very important work. She let me have a copy of the draft going to the publisher. I was impressed by the scope and erudition of the book, but I was very moved by Cathy's personal accounts of soldiers. I had grown very impatient with leftist stereotyping of the military and the omnipresent factual misrepresentation of the military by both the corporate and leftist press (for utterly different reasons). Here was a very visible and active faculty radical from the state's flagship university who had actually talked to soldiers and ex-soldiers, and who presented them in all their humanity and complexity. I would later learn that Cathy grew up in a military household. Hollywood's stereotypical mystique of the military and the left's simplified demonization of the military are abstractions that don't hold up well when you've seen your father, a colonel, rummaging around the bathroom, paralyzed by a spouse's anger, sick and vulnerable, playful, reflective, sad, silly... or seen your mother wash his dirty drawers. If there is a chasm between these two worlds, the communities of the armed forces and "the left," then it is a very deep chasm, but a close one over which we can easily jump. Just don't look down. I jumped, and so did Cathy. And when the time comes for the deep transformation of this society, a significant portion of the armed forces will either support us or refuse to attack us. Otherwise it won't happen. If we accept that, then we need to study the military. We study bourgeois economists, so we can study workers in uniform. We need credibility when we declare on military matters, and credibility is surrendered when we mask complexities in the interest of short-term polemical advantage. In particular, if we are to reach out to the people inside the military, most of them working class, then we have to do two things. We have to get our facts straight. And we have to think about their experience critically. Most soldiers are voracious readers. One reason I failed to read much from the left while I was in the military, or even from the mainstream press (which soldiers mistrust enormously-are we listening?), is that within two paragraphs I'd generally encounter some technical or factual error, or some preposterous stereotype. Fact is, many on the left have not taken the leap, from moral judgment and theoretical pigeon-holing to study and criticism-alas, symptomatic of the larger malaise on the left. People rely on impressions, largely gained from second-hand polemics or entertainment media. And we miss much. Short-cut thinking always misses much. The military is a violent macho culture. Surely that's no surprise. So are many team sports. Often enough that judgment ends examination. Warfare did much to shape the gender roles that now dominate our culture, even those aspects of the male script that are no longer recognizable as martial. Military institutions exist as the primary external armed body of the state, and in many countries as the internal armed body as well. All true. Military organizations are bureaucratic and they cover up their crimes and mistakes. Well and good. So do corporations, and there are workers there, too. But how many on the left will acknowledge that the institution with the most effective affirmative action program in the country, at least with regard to race, is the United States Army? Interracial marriage is more common in the military than the civil sector by orders of magnitude. How many on the left recognize that on a military base there resides a community that is in some respects more socialist than capitalist? Every resident of a US military base has come to expect high-quality schools, a plenitude of commons-including parks, recreations centers, gymnasiums, stadiums, swimming pools, cinemas, craft shops, hiking trails, community centers, and nature preserves-a three-tiered universal health care system, counseling centers, and safe, well-designed residential neighborhoods where housing, maintenance, and utilities are provided free. The disparity between the highest and lowest pay in the military is less than 13 to 1, compared to an average of 458 to 1 in the civil sector. The majority who remain in the military remain there for these reasons. It never occurs to them that what they like about the military is socialist. They frequently hate the deployments, the occasional violence, the bureaucratic backbiting, and the ubiquitous incompetence. They put up with all these negatives because they and their families enjoy some modicum of security and well-being. Soldiers know some of the concrete possibilities of socialism better than the rest of us. They've lived them. When we refuse to take up the issue of women or gays in the military-masking contradictions by saying we are "against" the military anyway-we are missing the point that this is an issue of gender equality in federal employment. Queer people are isolated altogether, and women are legally excluded from the majority of positions (not specialties, that is different), and from those career tracks within which advancement is the fastest. Little understood outside the military is the negrophobia of the Special Operations subset within the otherwise thoroughly integrated armed forces. Here too is a wedge, a teachable moment for Black soldiers when we might begin to organize. Every successful revolution requires either the neutralization or active participation of military people. It's time we factor that into our thinking. It's time we thought about organizing within the military. We need them, and they need us. <http://www.freedomroad.org/militarymatters_1_nov02.html> _______________________________________________ Leninist-International mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] To change your options or unsubscribe go to: http://lists.econ.utah.edu/mailman/listinfo/leninist-international _______________________________________________ Leninist-International mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] To change your options or unsubscribe go to: http://lists.econ.utah.edu/mailman/listinfo/leninist-international
