On Aug 5, 2010, at 12:56, Per Øyvind Øygard wrote: > Couple problems. Many boxsets have discs of new/unreleased content. These > discs necessarily need to have boxset naming, and need to be linked to. > Linking "Johnny's Boxset Beats (disc 5: The Returnening)" as the next disc > for "Johnny Sings the Blues", seems rather odd to me. > > Also, individual releases will very often share release groups with > regional dupes, remasters etc. Can you really justify moving these to a > boxset group and not changing the name? Would it not make more sense to > make a dupe with boxset titling and link the discs together, so interested > parties can traverse the disc chains to get the whole boxset? > > Anyway, doesn't NGS solve this with per-release-event release titles (at > least so my testing indicates)? Ideally we should probably register > release/disc names seperately and have Picard construct the boxset names, > but yeah...
All good points; I hadn't considered the other uses of Release Groups as much. I wasn't aware of the changes in NGS in this regard, but yes, that would appear to help considerably. Thanks for your thoughts (you too, Paul!). :) Cheers, Andrewski _______________________________________________ MusicBrainz-style mailing list MusicBrainz-style@lists.musicbrainz.org http://lists.musicbrainz.org/mailman/listinfo/musicbrainz-style
