Of course what you have said about advantages over this format as compared to the web forum format are true to some extent, but I would argue that the email served format is superior over any web page based format if only for the simple reason that the postings arrive to each person by email, and so don't require a visit to a web page to view them... I for one would participate less frequently if I had to go to a page to view the postings... I have been a party to similar discussions regarding format in other lists, and all have noted a trend toward the list as opposed to away from it... this is more convenient and more useful to most readers, and while it makes it harder to get advertising money to support it, it is also for that reason of the absence of the ads that it is more pleasing... If there were a vote, mine would be to remain as an email list rather than switch to a discussion group web page... I would be less frequent a visitor to such a forum... My two cents... Best regards, Paul Silver Paul Silver Photography & SilverLight Studios Architecture, Interiors, Fashion, Musicians, Theatrical, Sports, Industrial, Corporate. http://www.silver-light.com [EMAIL PROTECTED]