I think both phases of this project are a very bad idea and I do not approve of the strategy.
The Solaris security team did a similar analysis for 'pfexec' vs 'sudo' for almost identical reasons as this case. Like this case we planed to initially ship a symlink pfexec -> sudo and later enhance pfexec with the functionality that sudo had. In the end we choose not to do that because it as more engineering effort, it would never be perfect and there really was no harm in having the real sudo installed on the system. So that strategy was abandoned and now Solaris/OpenSolaris has the real sudo. I strongly suggest that this case be withdrawn and a new case be filed to just ship top. This is is also misnamed there are no prstat enhancements in this case just a confusing symlink from prstat -> top. I'm think that prstat could do with some enhancements but this case didn't actually provide any. -- Darren J Moffat
