RE: (313) Kraftwerk NOT a bootleg

2008-03-03 Thread Odeluga, Ken
Yeah strictly speaking that is correct terminology Michael.

Goes without saying that a release done without the permission of the
artist is morally wrong whatever you call it, but I'll say it anyway! :)

-Original Message-
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
[mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
Sent: 03 March 2008 16:50
To: Thor Teague
Cc: list 313; Odeluga, Ken
Subject: Re: (313) Kraftwerk NOT a bootleg


> I am against buying bootlegged (which in my mind means pirated) vinyl.

technically

Bootlegs are recordings of unreleased recordings (live shows, stuff off
radio, unplanned songs, etc.)

Pirated recordings are unofficial copies of real releases or planned
recordings that are yet unreleased. A pirated recording doesn't have to
try and mimic an official release

Counterfeits are pirated recordings that do mimic official releases

so this note in discogs:
-
In 2006 a bootleg (counterfeit) of this album was re-issued in a
gatefold cover with the first disc in yellow vinyl and the second disc
in blue vinyl. There is also an edition of the re-release with the first
disc in blue and the second in red vinyl.
-

is inaccurate - it is a pirated counterfeit
not a bootleg

MEK


Re: (313) Kraftwerk NOT a bootleg

2008-03-03 Thread Michael . Elliot-Knight
> I am against buying bootlegged (which in my mind means pirated) vinyl.

technically

Bootlegs are recordings of unreleased recordings (live shows, stuff off
radio, unplanned songs, etc.)

Pirated recordings are unofficial copies of real releases or planned
recordings that are yet unreleased.
A pirated recording doesn't have to try and mimic an official release

Counterfeits are pirated recordings that do mimic official releases

so this note in discogs:
-
In 2006 a bootleg (counterfeit) of this album was re-issued in a gatefold
cover with the first disc in yellow vinyl and the second disc in blue
vinyl. There is also an edition of the re-release with the first disc in
blue and the second in red vinyl.
-

is inaccurate - it is a pirated counterfeit
not a bootleg

MEK