[IxDA Discuss] Dialog Position

2008-11-16 Thread Maxim Soloviev
Hello everyone :) I'm working on UI for web application and I need to show several dialogs, one of them is confirmation of deleting the file. So I'm wondering -- what is the best position for modal dialog: A. Center of screen B. Near control that caused dialog appearance C. Near mouse cursor posit

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Clock Burn-In

2008-11-16 Thread William Brall
True true. But if the clock is always on, those pixels will fail at the same rate that they would in either case. So the display will get dimmer over time, rather than show 88:88 dim with the rest of the screen bright. It turns illegibility into readable by dark. So if you take all the other pre

Re: [IxDA Discuss] perceived problems with personas

2008-11-16 Thread Ali Naqvi
Hi Michael, http://www.snitker.com/public/dokumenter/A4personasplakat2.pdf This has been made by a Danish PHd. Ali . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Posted from the new ixda.org http://www.ixda.org/discuss?post=35624 __

Re: [IxDA Discuss] perceived problems with personas

2008-11-16 Thread Mike Stiso
> Creating stereotypes and aggregates is useful in > many endeavors. Some endeavors. But if decisions are being based on a stereotype of something that doesn't actually exist -- an aggregate in which bits and pieces represent characteristics of different users, but in which the whole represents no

Re: [IxDA Discuss] perceived problems with personas

2008-11-16 Thread William Evans
Personas are not meant to represent one person or user. They are meant to represent classes or segments of users. This is a valid use of them. Creating stereotypes and aggregates is useful in many endeavors. You by default will always design for someone- question is whether that person is t

Re: [IxDA Discuss] perceived problems with personas

2008-11-16 Thread Marijke Rijsberman
Michael, I'm glad you posted your concerns. I think personas are a great tool for designers trying to resist the natural slide into accommodating every possible scenario in the world. In principle. There are definitely situations when I think they are very helpful. However, in practice I've seen

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Clock Burn-In

2008-11-16 Thread j. eric townsend
William Brall wrote: the on pixels off. This will prevent burn in, as all the pixels will get exactly the same amount of wear, Just to be pedantic, this will not prevent burn-in. This solution causes the display to fail sooner-but-evenly. *All* the pixels will wear out at the same time --

Re: [IxDA Discuss] perceived problems with personas

2008-11-16 Thread mark schraad
Great article to mention Joshua. It is a great read for those of us in an MBA heavy corporate environment. I find myself coming back to read and reference this article often. Martin touches this in another somewhat charged article from the same publication called "designing in hostile ter

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Clock Burn-In

2008-11-16 Thread William Brall
I say avoid analogue clocks. People younger than I am are less and less likely to be able to read an analogue clock. In point of fact. I have to decipher them. This means I can't 'read' them. I can figure them out, the same way I can figure out a word I've never read before. But it takes a lot mor

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Best Practices for Mouseover Layers

2008-11-16 Thread William Brall
I actually think we can reach a semi-conclusion here: -Hover is best used for non-essential but useful 'extra' info. (tooltips, next-page previews, link highlights) -Hover can be used for functionality if it is an extension with a good default, or if it has a logical backup. (a second-row drop out

Re: [IxDA Discuss] perceived problems with personas

2008-11-16 Thread Mike Stiso
> Personas are a classic example of a method that is "valid" in Martin's terms. That's an interesting article, but I must admit it has me confused as to whether personas would be an attempt at validity or reliability. I see personas as an attempt to represent a product's users, the goal being to r

Re: [IxDA Discuss] perceived problems with personas

2008-11-16 Thread Joshua Seiden
I've probably posted this reference before, but Roger Martin wrote a good article comparing two ways of thinking about problems and processes. He calls this dynamic reliability vs. validity. "Reliability seeks to produce consistent, predictable outcomes by utilizing a system that is restricted

Re: [IxDA Discuss] perceived problems with personas

2008-11-16 Thread William Evans
The myths about the efficacy or not of archtypes in design and design research tend to be promulgated by those that 1. Can't do them; 2. Have never done real design or ethnographic research; 3. To justify the tried and true fact that while most companies and clients say they want to do (ins

[IxDA Discuss] perceived problems with personas

2008-11-16 Thread Michael Stiso
Hi, all. I was inspired to post this question by the very interesting ACD/UCD discussion, during which the personas concept has frequently been mentioned. I've always been a little uncertain of personas, but many people seem to love them, and so I'm wondering if I'm missing or misunderstanding some