Re: [IxDA Discuss] Agreeing to disagree

2009-10-04 Thread Gilberto Medrano
This is an accurate clarification. Adding to what Andy said, aesthetics also has a functional aspect to it (reinforcing usability decisions through Semiotics - i.e. a particular texture in a widget means "possibility to drag"). It's up to the designer in which way she/he wants to use the tools an

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Agreeing to disagree

2009-10-04 Thread Andy Budd
Hey Guys, Not wanting to jump into somebody else's conversation half way through, but I think the key word in the sentence "the seductive power of the design of certain material and virtual objects can transcend issues of price and performance for buyers and users alike." is CAN. I don't

[IxDA Discuss] Agreeing to disagree

2009-10-04 Thread Eric Reiss
Dear Don, Sorry to have pissed you off in my message to this list of September 21. Here, I said: "Dave- Don Norman is dead wrong about this: "that something emotionally appealing can basically make up for its lack of usability". I may love a beautiful object, but I didn't buy Philippe Starck's