Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-26 Thread Kontra
> My guess is that android based phones over time will be about > performance first On the contrary, therein lies Android's Achilles Heel. The UX on Android phones will rely on these factors: 1. Back-end service hardware 2. Back-end service software 3. Front-end client hardware 4. F

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-26 Thread greg
I agree totally, and this is the point I was trying to make. I would even add the impact of the business model into the total experience of a product and the cost to the environment. Good design finds the sweet spot between the tech, the biz model and the experience that delights and meets the nee

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-25 Thread Jarod Tang
Hi Greg, It's still part of the user experience. I would like to say what you addressed still belongs to bad design vs good design discussion. Cheers, -- Jarod On Fri, Sep 26, 2008 at 1:58 PM, greg <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > One often overlooked element of Google's success is performance. > Pe

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-25 Thread greg
One often overlooked element of Google's success is performance. Performance for cloud based systems is crucial. You can have the best design in the world and it will get trumped every time by performance. Latency is at this moment the most important issue in the experience of cloud based systems a

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-25 Thread David Malouf
there is still a lot to be learned/gained from the blog reports that already have access to it. -- dave On Thu, Sep 25, 2008 at 4:19 PM, seth b <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Seth, the phone came out in Stores on Tues here in the US. > > Please see your favorite tech blog for an unwrapping: Engad

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-25 Thread seth b
> Seth, the phone came out in Stores on Tues here in the US. > Please see your favorite tech blog for an unwrapping: Engadget, Gizmodo, > other > Wrong. It comes out October 22nd. They just previewed it Tuesday. seth - subimage llc - http://sublog.subimage.com - Cashb

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-25 Thread Jarod Tang
I beg your differ here. Frankly speaking, most of the Google products is from outside except their search engine. Some bought product but be redesigned by google, Youtube ( redesigned, and it's not a bad redesign ), Picasa (redesigned, make it as a integrated part of Google services. It's really a

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-25 Thread Andrei Herasimchuk
On Sep 25, 2008, at 9:13 AM, Jarod Tang wrote: Besides these, Picasa is quit good designed Picasa was designed by an ex-Metacreations team and then bought by Google. Picasa, GMail, Google Reader ... , all get high rank from their user. Ok... three out of fifty. One of which was original

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-25 Thread Jarod Tang
On Fri, Sep 26, 2008 at 12:03 AM, Andrei Herasimchuk <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > On Sep 25, 2008, at 1:58 AM, Tamlyn Rhodes wrote: > >> In my experience it is only graphic designers who think that Google >> products are poorly designed. Everyone else just marvels at how easy >> they are to use and

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-25 Thread Andrei Herasimchuk
On Sep 25, 2008, at 1:58 AM, Tamlyn Rhodes wrote: In my experience it is only graphic designers who think that Google products are poorly designed. Everyone else just marvels at how easy they are to use and gets on with it. I'd argue that Google products are, in the main, exceptionally well desi

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-25 Thread mark schraad
There is a huge and deep relationship between the need for interface work and how well you technology works on the back end. Part of the elegance and simplicity of Songza was due to how well google performed. The interface designer's job is very often making a crappy technology more tolerab

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-25 Thread David Malouf
Seth, the phone came out in Stores on Tues here in the US. Please see your favorite tech blog for an unwrapping: Engadget, Gizmodo, other -- dave On Thu, Sep 25, 2008 at 12:36 AM, seth b <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > On Wed, Sep 24, 2008 at 2:22 PM, David Malouf <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > I

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-25 Thread Will Callaghan
I find some Google Apps more intuitive than others. GMail isn't pretty but it's generally sound, aspects of Analytics and Street View I find appealing too. Perhaps what Google needs is an overarching god on the throne like Jobs is reputed to be at Apple. You're sure to have read this Wired article

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-25 Thread Tamlyn Rhodes
In my experience it is only graphic designers who think that Google products are poorly designed. Everyone else just marvels at how easy they are to use and gets on with it. I'd argue that Google products are, in the main, exceptionally well designed from an interaction point of view. Take the ori

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-25 Thread Peter Knocke
"What part of Google's current product offerings would lead you to believe there's systemic consistency, cross-product cohesion and anything but an amateurish aesthetic quality to it, especially with regard to a comparison to Apple? Yes there is basically no cross-product cohesion in the google wo

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-25 Thread Kontra
> different handset manufacturers jumping on board Haven't we seen that movie before? One codebase trying to cater to myriad hardware "partners" at every iteration and, in the process, getting bloated and chained down with legacy considerations beyond redemption? Yep, "write once, run on every m

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-25 Thread Kontra
> The interface is really disconnected, inconsistent, and almost has an > amateur quality to it. G1 is a revolution: open source OS, a free-for-all for developers, diverse devices to run on...Oops, we had that revolution already on the desktop. For consumers, how did that turn out? Its manufactu

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-25 Thread Daniel Szuc
Having moved our company email to Google Apps, I am excited at the prospect of having a phone that can connect seamlessly to my contacts, email, chat and calendar. The stuff around the platform should improve with different handset manufacturers jumping on board and integrating it with different as

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-24 Thread Jarod Tang
Chrome ( until now ) maybe good an example of bad design based on short using experience. but it's hard to say about G1 until now. Cheers, -- Jarod On Thu, Sep 25, 2008 at 11:05 AM, David Malouf <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Hey! BW just posted this diddy on the G1 Design process. :) > http://www

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-24 Thread seth b
> The iPhone horn doesn't need any more tooting, but this really > reflects how great the apple team is with UI development and how bad > others are. > > What does everyone else think? No comments on the Android platform UI, but what I've seen I've liked. Physically, I find the iPhone lacking bec

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-24 Thread William Evans
Oh this is so ripe ... Please .. Holidays are only a week away... will evans emotive architect & hedonic designer [EMAIL PROTECTED] 617.281.1281 twitter: semanticwill aim: semanticwill gtalk: wkevans4 skype: semanticwill _ Sent via iPhone On Sep 25, 2008, at 12:15 AM, An

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-24 Thread seth b
On Wed, Sep 24, 2008 at 2:22 PM, David Malouf <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I think my read on the lack of conversation on G1 here is that I > don't know a single soul who bought it or cared about it. It is a > non-issue in this community. I think the only people talking about it > are developers, a

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-24 Thread Andrei Herasimchuk
On Sep 24, 2008, at 5:36 PM, David Malouf wrote: I have been saying that Google is an "non-design" organization for years. Thanx Andrei!!! 8-) G-d Damn It we agree again! Is this becoming a habit? We won't truly agree on much of the larger picture until you change your stance that "inte

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-24 Thread David Malouf
Hey! BW just posted this diddy on the G1 Design process. :) http://www.businessweek.com/innovate/next/archives/2008/09/inside_googles.html?campaign_id=rss_innovate -- dave . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Posted from the new ixda.org http://www.ixda.org/discuss

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-24 Thread Andreas Ringdal
Like anything Googely, it is going to be beta until it can either be declared a success, or fade away. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Posted from the new ixda.org http://www.ixda.org/discuss?post=33456

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-24 Thread David Malouf
I have been saying that Google is an "non-design" organization for years. Thanx Andrei!!! 8-) G-d Damn It we agree again! Is this becoming a habit? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Posted from the new ixda.org http://www.ixda.org/discuss?post=33456 __

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-24 Thread Andrei Herasimchuk
On Sep 24, 2008, at 9:10 AM, Peter Knocke wrote: The interface is really disconnected, inconsistent, and almost has an amateur quality to it. (not the good kind) It not only boggles my mind they they would release something so disconnected, but that so many people are so excited for it. If an

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-24 Thread David Malouf
I think my read on the lack of conversation on G1 here is that I don't know a single soul who bought it or cared about it. It is a non-issue in this community. I think the only people talking about it are developers, and even then I'm not hearing a heck of a lot about it. >From HTC's ugly retro Pa

Re: [IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-24 Thread Will Evans
"but to my surprise I haven't seen any G1 debates coming up here from the release this week." I think, for me at least - there is no way to debate or discuss something we haven't played with yet. IxD kinda depends on the ability to interact, and since I haven't, I won't comment. -- ~ will "Whe

[IxDA Discuss] G1 Android - case study in inconsistency

2008-09-24 Thread Peter Knocke
Sorry if I'm rehashing a conversation here, but to my surprise I haven't seen any G1 debates coming up here from the release this week. So I'll startOh my...what a mess. I really enjoy gizmodo's write up http://gizmodo.com/5053734/how-many-google-phone-engineers-does-it-take-to-tell-the-