Re: NAS-IP vs srcIP

2010-04-01 Thread Michael Lecuyer
Plenty of reasons - but one you won't have control over even in CoA is that it could be proxied. The NAS-IPAddress is used in the CoA request packet to tell the NAS which client should receive the packet. Marlon Duksa wrote: Hi everyone - Can anyone think of a reason why the NAS-IP and the s

Re: NAS-IP vs srcIP

2010-04-01 Thread James J J Hooper
--On 01 April 2010 09:39 -0700 Marlon Duksa wrote: Hi everyone - Can anyone think of a reason why the NAS-IP and the scr-IP of the access-req packet should not be the same? If the NAS-IP is configurable in the NAS, then the NAS-IP can be set to the IP address other than the src-ip of the NAS

Re: NAS-IP vs srcIP

2010-04-01 Thread Alan DeKok
Marlon Duksa wrote: > Can anyone think of a reason why the NAS-IP and the scr-IP of the > access-req packet should not be the same? Many. There is *no* requirement in RADIUS that they be identical. When a packet is proxied, the NAS-IP-Address stays the same, but the source IP changes. Ala

Re: NAS-IP vs srcIP

2010-04-01 Thread Phil Mayers
On 04/01/2010 05:39 PM, Marlon Duksa wrote: Hi everyone - Can anyone think of a reason why the NAS-IP and the scr-IP of the access-req packet should not be the same? If the NAS-IP is configurable in the NAS, then the NAS-IP can be set to the IP address other than the src-ip of the NAS that is us

RE: NAS-IP vs srcIP

2010-04-01 Thread John Kane
> Hi everyone - > Can anyone think of a reason why the NAS-IP and the scr-IP of the access-req packet should not be the same? One of NAS is on the other side of a load balancer, source IP is not the same as NAS-IP. John This message is confidential to Prodea Systems, Inc unless otherwise in

NAS-IP vs srcIP

2010-04-01 Thread Marlon Duksa
Hi everyone - Can anyone think of a reason why the NAS-IP and the scr-IP of the access-req packet should not be the same? If the NAS-IP is configurable in the NAS, then the NAS-IP can be set to the IP address other than the src-ip of the NAS that is used in reqular FreeRadius accounting/authorizat