Re: [classlib] do we have any current instances where we've chosen to disagree with the spec or RI?

2006-03-07 Thread Geir Magnusson Jr
Tim Ellison wrote: Yes we do. I'm not convinced that logging them in JIRA is the right thing -- I'd like to see them a bit closer to the code. Having them in JIRA doesn't exclude doing anything else, just serves as an additional tracking system - a central directory of how we deviate so we

Re: [classlib] do we have any current instances where we've chosen to disagree with the spec or RI?

2006-03-07 Thread Tim Ellison
Yes we do. I'm not convinced that logging them in JIRA is the right thing -- I'd like to see them a bit closer to the code. IMHO when we agree on a departure from the spec/RI then the differences should be embodied in an API test case. We should expect the test to pass on harmony code, and fail

[classlib] do we have any current instances where we've chosen to disagree with the spec or RI?

2006-03-07 Thread Geir Magnusson Jr
If so, lets be sure to log them in JIRA - I created a category for this (I forget the name, but it will be obvious...) geir