Re: [j-nsp] J/SRX ICMP handling

2013-06-30 Thread Dale Shaw
Hi all, Just tying up a loose end here -- After lots of to-and-fro with the JTAC (partially due to me getting sidetracked with other things), I confirmed with them that the SRX will drop ICMP response packets if the SRX did not forward the packet that ultimately triggered the ICMP response. This

Re: [j-nsp] J/SRX ICMP handling

2013-04-25 Thread Per Westerlund
In the context of this conversation it is implicit that IPsec is used, with st0.x interfaces. They have nowhere to attach filters! To be able to use filters with st0.x interfaces, you have to wrap one more layer of interface. GRE is one obvious solution (can have attached filters), can probably

Re: [j-nsp] J/SRX ICMP handling

2013-04-25 Thread Tim Eberhard
Selective packet services is always an option assuming you're in a branch srx (650 and below). Basically just write a firewall filter that allows icmp with a then action of packet mode. Keeping track of icmp may not add any value but be aware with SPS you now lose NAT, screens and IDP (which yo

Re: [j-nsp] J/SRX ICMP handling

2013-04-25 Thread Dale Shaw
Hi Klaus, On Thu, Apr 25, 2013 at 4:44 PM, Klaus Groeger wrote: > > "set security flow allow-icmp-without-flow" This doesn't seem to be a valid command - at least not on 10.4R11. I couldn't find a reference in the documentation either. The closest I can find is "security idp sensor-configuratio

Re: [j-nsp] J/SRX ICMP handling

2013-04-24 Thread Klaus Groeger
Hi Dale just give "set security flow allow-icmp-without-flow" a try Regards Klaus — Sent from Mailbox for iPhone On Thu, Apr 25, 2013 at 7:35 AM, Dale Shaw wrote: > Hi all, > This post relates to a previous post of mine on asymmetrically routed > UDP traffic: > https://puck.nether.net/

[j-nsp] J/SRX ICMP handling

2013-04-24 Thread Dale Shaw
Hi all, This post relates to a previous post of mine on asymmetrically routed UDP traffic: https://puck.nether.net/pipermail/juniper-nsp/2012-December/024878.html It seems as though a J/SRX in flow mode will drop ICMP packets such as unreachable and ttl-exceeded if, after consulting the session t