Re: [j-nsp] MX80 no more hash-key option in 12.2?

2012-11-06 Thread Pavel Lunin
Sorry for replying an old thread but my two cents about LB on Trio. > Please take into consideration that the engineers that designed TRIO LB > decided to simplify the LB options traditionally available on other > chipsets, so you may find missing ones under the enhanced-hash-key. TRIO LB > algo

Re: [j-nsp] MX80 no more hash-key option in 12.2?

2012-11-06 Thread Saku Ytti
On (2012-10-24 01:12 +0400), Tima Maryin wrote: > Check KB24339 also > (Hash key computation on MPC cards) Is this accurate? - Payload recognition uses the following criteria to estimate the nature of the payload: IPv4 assumes the first nibble, which follows the bottom label, is 0x4. If thi

Re: [j-nsp] MX80 no more hash-key option in 12.2?

2012-10-23 Thread Tima Maryin
On 23.10.2012 21:09, Paul Vlaar wrote: This definitely seems like a bug. Worth submitting to Juniper TAC? I don't think so. Check KB24339 also (Hash key computation on MPC cards) ___ juniper-nsp mailing list juniper-nsp@puck.nether.net https://puck

Re: [j-nsp] MX80 no more hash-key option in 12.2?

2012-10-23 Thread Paul Vlaar
On 23/10/12 6:37 PM, Olivier Benghozi wrote: > I had previously (like you) the hash-key stuff configured on some > MX80 gear, and removed it after reading David Roy's answer. > > I can confirm that the removal of this stuff left the tfeb in a > strange state (running 11.4R5), with some funny logs

Re: [j-nsp] MX80 no more hash-key option in 12.2?

2012-10-23 Thread Olivier Benghozi
Hi Paul, I had previously (like you) the hash-key stuff configured on some MX80 gear, and removed it after reading David Roy's answer. I can confirm that the removal of this stuff left the tfeb in a strange state (running 11.4R5), with some funny logs at the commit (tfeb0 jnh_loadbalance_hashk

Re: [j-nsp] MX80 no more hash-key option in 12.2?

2012-10-23 Thread magno
Hi Paul, with MX TRIO you don't need to configure anything to achieve almost the behaviour you need (almost = not per packet, read below). TCP and UDP ports are taken into account on TRIO by default for both IPv6 and IPv4. Please be aware of some more info: - TRIO doesn't support per-packet LB

Re: [j-nsp] MX80 no more hash-key option in 12.2?

2012-10-23 Thread Paul Vlaar
Hi Magno, that clarifies things a bit more for me, thank you. However, am I right to conclude that I still need the hash-key stanza for our 11.2 MX80s to make IPv6 source/destination hashing work for load balancing? As for what I am trying to do, well, that is pretty simple. We have ECMP for a n

Re: [j-nsp] MX80 no more hash-key option in 12.2?

2012-10-23 Thread magno
Hi Paul! Leaving the hash-key stanza enabled for MX80 leaves room to unexpected behaviours as you could observe yourself. the only supported way to tweak load balancing input paramters for TRIO based devices (I mean MPCs and MX80 for instance) is to use the enhanced-hash-key stanza. The culpr

Re: [j-nsp] MX80 no more hash-key option in 12.2?

2012-10-23 Thread Paul Vlaar
Doug, On 23/10/12 9:52 AM, Doug Hanks wrote: > Pretty much. enhanced-hash-hey does a lot by default. Harry can elaborate. So on 11.2 at least, enhanced-hash-key doesn't offer me any options to set, as the defaults should already enable port based hashing: mx80# set forwarding-options enhanced-ha

Re: [j-nsp] MX80 no more hash-key option in 12.2?

2012-10-23 Thread Doug Hanks
Pretty much. enhanced-hash-hey does a lot by default. Harry can elaborate. On 10/23/12 2:38 AM, "Paul Vlaar" wrote: >On 23/10/12 12:59 AM, Doug Hanks wrote: >> hash-key = DPC (should never been been on or used on the MX80 - doesn't >> even do anything when configured) >> >> >> enhanced-hash-k

Re: [j-nsp] MX80 no more hash-key option in 12.2?

2012-10-23 Thread Paul Vlaar
On 23/10/12 12:59 AM, Doug Hanks wrote: > hash-key = DPC (should never been been on or used on the MX80 - doesn't > even do anything when configured) > > > enhanced-hash-key = MPC (which works on the MX80 as it's based on Trio) mx80# set family inet ? Possible completions: + apply-groups

Re: [j-nsp] MX80 no more hash-key option in 12.2?

2012-10-22 Thread Doug Hanks
hash-key = DPC (should never been been on or used on the MX80 - doesn't even do anything when configured) enhanced-hash-key = MPC (which works on the MX80 as it's based on Trio) On 10/22/12 5:36 PM, "Paul Vlaar" wrote: >I just upgraded one of our MX80s to 12.2R1.3, and the following occurs: >

[j-nsp] MX80 no more hash-key option in 12.2?

2012-10-22 Thread Paul Vlaar
I just upgraded one of our MX80s to 12.2R1.3, and the following occurs: mx80# show forwarding-options [...] ## ## Warning: configuration block ignored: unsupported platform (mx80-48t) ## hash-key { family inet { layer-3; layer-4; } family inet6 { layer-3;