Re: [j-nsp] PIM neighbor not coming up on MVPN

2011-12-03 Thread Mark Tinka
On Thursday, December 01, 2011 03:27:01 PM Jose María Carrera wrote: > 1) This is BGP-Signalled MVPN. See the full bgp config > below I haven't used NG-MVPN with a PIM/GRE control and data plane as well, but I'm curious - since you're already using NG- MVPN where PIM mecahnisms are handled in B

Re: [j-nsp] PIM neighbor not coming up on MVPN

2011-12-01 Thread Mark Tinka
On Thursday, December 01, 2011 02:48:53 PM Per Granath wrote: > tunnel-services are only needed on PE routers. > There's also the alternative to use vrf-table-lable > instead of tunnel-interfaces. We use 'vt-' interfaces to avoid Multicast packet duplication (I know, it sounds ironic, right, he

Re: [j-nsp] PIM neighbor not coming up on MVPN

2011-11-30 Thread Jose María Carrera
eighbour's up Again, thanks a lot for your help BR /Jose Maria -Mensaje original- De: Stacy W. Smith [mailto:st...@acm.org] Enviado el: miércoles, 30 de noviembre de 2011 17:33 Para: Jose María Carrera CC: juniper-nsp@puck.nether.net Asunto: Re: [j-nsp] PIM neighbor not coming up on

Re: [j-nsp] PIM neighbor not coming up on MVPN

2011-11-30 Thread Per Granath
> I read that the tunnel-services statement has to be configured under the > [chassis hardware pic] But the question is: does it have to be configured on > all the routers along the path to the other PE router? tunnel-services are only needed on PE routers. There's also the alternative to use vrf-

Re: [j-nsp] PIM neighbor not coming up on MVPN

2011-11-30 Thread Mark Tinka
On Wednesday, November 30, 2011 11:46:17 PM Jose María Carrera wrote: > CE (receiver) PE1--P1P2-PE2--CE > (RP)---source > > Does it need to be configured on PE1, P1, P2 and PE2? Or > only on the PE routers, which are running the MVPN ? If NG-MVPN, PIM is only needed on P

Re: [j-nsp] PIM neighbor not coming up on MVPN

2011-11-30 Thread Stacy W. Smith
Rosen or BGP-signalled MVPN? If BGP-signalled, what type of provider tunnel? Which PIM neighbor is not coming up? --Stacy On Nov 30, 2011, at 8:46 AM, Jose María Carrera wrote: > Hello Experts > > One questions regarding the use of MVPN (JUNOS 10.4) > > I read that the tunnel-services stat

[j-nsp] PIM neighbor not coming up on MVPN

2011-11-30 Thread Jose María Carrera
Hello Experts One questions regarding the use of MVPN (JUNOS 10.4) I read that the tunnel-services statement has to be configured under the [chassis hardware pic] But the question is: does it have to be configured on all the routers along the path to the other PE router? The setup is like this: