Re: MD: mini vs mp3 recorder

2000-07-10 Thread Dan Frakes
las <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >I have read here that the sound quality of ATRAC is far superior to >Mp3. I am going to have to take people's word for this. I have a DVD >player that plays Mp3s and most sound pretty good. But I don't have >the time to try AB testing MD vs Mp3. Trust me, it's

Re: MD: mini vs mp3 recorder

2000-07-10 Thread Dan Frakes
=== = NB: Over 50% of this message is QUOTED, please = = be more selective when quoting text = === "Timothy P. Stockman" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote

Re: MD: mini vs mp3 recorder

2000-07-10 Thread Timothy P. Stockman
> I think in > 5 years you might be looking at $20 instead of $100. Maybe at best. So that > will still make solid state unpracticed. (Even at $10 it is too high) FLASH prices have (and will continue) to drop dramatically as production quantities soar. Manufacturers have been perfecting mult

RE: MD: mini vs mp3 recorder

2000-07-10 Thread Simon Barnes
Larry wrote: > I really don't see how the cost of memory could ever drop > that low. I think in > 5 years you might be looking at $20 instead of $100. One might just as easily guess that you wouldn't be able to GIVE the stuff away in that time frame. simon --

Re: MD: mini vs mp3 recorder

2000-07-09 Thread las
"Timothy P. Stockman" wrote: > I think that solid state memory media *is* the wave of the future. However, > I do see some drawbacks: > > 1) Right now, the cost of solid state is very high compared to MD: $100 vs > $2.50 for the same amount of storage. > I really don't see how the cost of mem

Re: MD: mini vs mp3 recorder

2000-07-09 Thread Timothy P. Stockman
I think that solid state memory media *is* the wave of the future. However, I do see some drawbacks: 1) Right now, the cost of solid state is very high compared to MD: $100 vs $2.50 for the same amount of storage. 2) Right now standalone MD recorders are a mature technology, which means they'

Re: MD: mini vs mp3 recorder

2000-07-09 Thread las
Hi Susan, First. Any media that comes with a fixed memory isn't even worth discussing, Second, I'm sure they will or already do make Mp3 recorders that will accept removable memory, like digital still cameras. But have you seen the prices of Flash card, Smart Media or Sony's so called Stick??

Re: MD: mini vs mp3 recorder

2000-07-09 Thread J. Coon
AFAIK, there are no real time MP3 recorderds. You can't take one to a jam, workshop or a concert and record it live. Even if you could, it won't sound as good as ATRAC on MD. I don't think you have the editing and titling capabilities either. They are for different audiences. MP3 is just mat