Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-26 Thread Iljitsch van Beijnum
On 26-aug-2005, at 2:56, Lewis Butler wrote: I didn't say anything about population density. I said the countries are all very very small (in terms of area) with the exception of Canada, The fact is it is easier for a country like South Korea or The Netherlands to string fiber all over

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-26 Thread Iljitsch van Beijnum
On 25-aug-2005, at 23:51, John Levine wrote: and as people have noted, the US is unusual both in being large and spread out. Canada, for example, has a gargantuan area, but just about everyone lives in the 100 mile wide strip along the southern border and everyone else lives in a few cities li

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-25 Thread Steve Gibbard
On Thu, 25 Aug 2005, Lewis Butler wrote: And what does every country ahead of the US have in common? Tiny populations. And what does every country but one have in common? Very small area. The US has states that are larger than 10 of the 11 countries ahead of use, COMBINED. I didn't say

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-25 Thread Lewis Butler
On 24 Aug 2005, at 18:38 , Joe Abley wrote: On 24-Aug-2005, at 19:16, Lewis Butler wrote: And what does every country ahead of the US have in common? Tiny populations. And waht does every country but one have in common? Very small area. The US has states taht are larger than 10 of

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-25 Thread Jared Mauch
On Thu, Aug 25, 2005 at 09:51:37PM -, John Levine wrote: > >> > So, of the 11 countries that the OECD thinks have greater broadband > >> > penetration than the USA, 6 are more densely-populated than the USA > >> > and 5 are not. > >> > >> I wonder how they figure population density... Is it

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-25 Thread John Levine
>> > So, of the 11 countries that the OECD thinks have greater broadband >> > penetration than the USA, 6 are more densely-populated than the USA >> > and 5 are not. >> >> I wonder how they figure population density... Is it just a matter of >> land area divided by the number of residents, or so

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-25 Thread John Levine
>> I once spoke to a construction manager at comcast for their >> network buildouts. With my local township, they need to have 20 homes >> per linear mile along the route to justify a build. > >Given it is Comcast, it appears that they are not interested. I know that >some companies will d

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-25 Thread Robert Bonomi
NANOG list > Subject: Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger > > > On Wed, 24 Aug 2005, Daniel Golding wrote: > > > > > I suggest you take another look at these numbers. Those countries with > > overall population densities lower than the US

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-25 Thread Simon Waters
On Thursday 25 Aug 2005 5:27 am, Joel Jaeggli wrote: > On Wed, 24 Aug 2005, Daniel Golding wrote: > > > > This is an issue of both distribution and density, not just density. > > So you're saying the US is screwed because of unique geography? Or is that > something poltical will can overcome? Si

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-25 Thread Iljitsch van Beijnum
On 25-aug-2005, at 3:31, Jared Mauch wrote: I once spoke to a construction manager at comcast for their network buildouts. With my local township, they need to have 20 homes per linear mile along the route to justify a build. Turns out that the US has a cable penetration of some 67%. (ht

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-24 Thread Joel Jaeggli
On Wed, 24 Aug 2005, Daniel Golding wrote: I suggest you take another look at these numbers. Those countries with overall population densities lower than the US's all have something in common - they are really cold. Iceland, Canada, Finland, Norway, Sweden. Folks in those countries are densely

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-24 Thread Sean Figgins
On Wed, 24 Aug 2005, Jared Mauch wrote: > I once spoke to a construction manager at comcast for their > network buildouts. With my local township, they need to have 20 homes > per linear mile along the route to justify a build. While my street > has 11 homes, and 3 adjacent (where my priv

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-24 Thread Randy Bush
> Not that this necessarily means anything, but I thought your > sentiments above could do with some numbers. prejudices and sentiments are immune to numbers randy

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-24 Thread Joe Abley
On 24-Aug-2005, at 22:43, Dan Golding wrote: I suggest you take another look at these numbers. Those countries with overall population densities lower than the US's all have something in common - they are really cold. Iceland, Canada, Finland, Norway, Sweden. Folks in those countries are dens

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-24 Thread Daniel Golding
On 8/24/05 7:38 PM, "Joe Abley" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > On 24-Aug-2005, at 19:16, Lewis Butler wrote: > >> And what does every country ahead of the US have in common? Tiny >> populations. >> >> And waht does every country but one have in common? Very small >> area. The US has state

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-24 Thread Jared Mauch
On Wed, Aug 24, 2005 at 07:15:44PM -0600, Sean Figgins wrote: > > On Wed, 24 Aug 2005, Joe Abley wrote: > > > So, of the 11 countries that the OECD thinks have greater broadband > > penetration than the USA, 6 are more densely-populated than the USA > > and 5 are not. > > I wonder how they figu

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-24 Thread Sean Figgins
On Wed, 24 Aug 2005, Joe Abley wrote: > So, of the 11 countries that the OECD thinks have greater broadband > penetration than the USA, 6 are more densely-populated than the USA > and 5 are not. I wonder how they figure population density... Is it just a matter of land area divided by the numbe

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-24 Thread Joe Abley
On 24-Aug-2005, at 19:16, Lewis Butler wrote: And what does every country ahead of the US have in common? Tiny populations. And waht does every country but one have in common? Very small area. The US has states taht are larger than 10 of the 11 countries ahed of use, COMBINED. (popu

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-24 Thread Lewis Butler
On 23 Aug 2005, at 17:04 , Michael Painter wrote: US is trailing other industrial countries in broadband penetration I'm not sure that's the case, AFAIK the US holds its own. Graph at the bottom of the article. http://www.mbc-thebridge.com/viewbridge.cfm?instance_id=304 And what does every

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-24 Thread Fergie (Paul Ferguson)
Amen, brother. ;-) - ferg -- Chris Boyd <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: For those outside the state or the US, Texas has some very odd political traditions and laws that are beyond explanation in email. -- "Fergie", a.k.a. Paul Ferguson Engineering Architecture for the Internet [EMAIL PROTECT

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-23 Thread Chris Boyd
Apologies for this possibly off topic post, but it does touch on the future speeds and feeds of networks. What follows is my opinion, not employer's, etc, etc, etc. On Aug 23, 2005, at 4:42 PM, Randy Bush wrote: does not take much convincing in dc that what is good for big business is go

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-23 Thread Larry Smith
On Tuesday 23 August 2005 17:52, Fergie (Paul Ferguson) wrote: > And just to make life more fun, it looks like there's an effort > afoot to get VoIP consumers to pay (read: tax) into the USF: > > New taxes could slam Net phone users > http://news.com.com/New+taxes+could+slam+Net+phone+users/2100-7

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-23 Thread Iljitsch van Beijnum
On 24-aug-2005, at 1:04, Michael Painter wrote: US is trailing other industrial countries in broadband penetration I'm not sure that's the case, AFAIK the US holds its own. Graph at the bottom of the article. http://www.mbc-thebridge.com/viewbridge.cfm?instance_id=304 No, the one you

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-23 Thread Michael Painter
US is trailing other industrial countries in broadband penetration I'm not sure that's the case, AFAIK the US holds its own. Graph at the bottom of the article. http://www.mbc-thebridge.com/viewbridge.cfm?instance_id=304

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-23 Thread Fergie (Paul Ferguson)
..and life is probably going to get a lot more interesting for service providers. All today, we have leaders in the field with completely opposite views of the word: U.S. Broadband Policy Exists -- And Works, Claims NTIA's Gallagher http://www.advancedippipeline.com/169600336 [and] Nortel chie

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-23 Thread Daniel Senie
At 05:45 PM 8/23/2005, Iljitsch van Beijnum wrote: On 23-aug-2005, at 23:24, Richard Z wrote: US is trailing other industrial countries in broadband penetration I'm not sure that's the case, AFAIK the US holds its own. because no carrier is interested in investing and building an infrastr

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-23 Thread Gary E. Miller
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Yo Iljitsch! On Tue, 23 Aug 2005, Iljitsch van Beijnum wrote: > So I guess the choice is between lots of broadband against monopoly prices or > less broadband at lower prices? You forget the third choice the AT&T taught us so well before the big br

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-23 Thread Iljitsch van Beijnum
On 23-aug-2005, at 23:24, Richard Z wrote: US is trailing other industrial countries in broadband penetration I'm not sure that's the case, AFAIK the US holds its own. because no carrier is interested in investing and building an infrastructure to be shared by their competitors. The only wa

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-23 Thread Randy Bush
Richard Z <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > I think that big carriers have successfully convinced regulators that > the telecom deregulation in late nineties was bad for the industry. does not take much convincing in dc that what is good for big business is good for america these days. > It certainly destro

Re: ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-23 Thread Richard Z
I think that big carriers have successfully convinced regulators that the telecom deregulation in late nineties was bad for the industry. It certainly destroyed quite a few big companies, e.g. MCI and AT&T. Also it dragged down a few big companies, e.g. Verizon has $40B debt. In the meantime, US i

ISP's In Uproar Over Verizon-MCI Merger

2005-08-23 Thread Fergie (Paul Ferguson)
Dan Neel writes in CRN.com: [snip] The California ISP Association (CISPA) claims the merger of Verizon Communications and MCI will threaten ISP business models. CISPA represents more than 180 ISPs. Mike Jackman, executive director of the Sacramento, Calif.-based organization, said the multibi