Re: New Trek film (Was Re: [TV orNotTV] Re: Oprah gives away something...panic ensues...) - No Spoilers

2009-05-07 Thread Brad Beam
- Original Message - From: David Bruggeman >I disagree with a couple of Ebert's points in his review (generally >positive, 3.5 out of 5), one I won't mention as it's sort of plot-centric. >He seems to think the flash and bang pushed out the more message-oriented >parts of Trek, I thin

New Trek film (Was Re: [TV orNotTV] Re: Oprah gives away something...panic ensues...) - No Spoilers

2009-05-07 Thread David Bruggeman
I enjoyed it very much. It's not a perfect film, but its problems aren't fatal. In the top third of Trek movies. FWIW, long time fan (from 1981). Didn't think they needed to make this film when I first heard about it, Nimoy's support persuaded me not to reject it, and the early promos convin