Re: [tiles2] Changes in tag libraries

2006-10-31 Thread Antonio Petrelli
[EMAIL PROTECTED] ha scritto: I'm sorry, but I'm behind in my reading and haven't been paying close enough attention to the messages on Tiles 2. You had to do it :-) All discussions on these kind of things have been made in the mailing list. Could you explain the reasoning behind this

RE: [tiles2] Changes in tag libraries

2006-10-31 Thread George.Dinwiddie
Antonio Petrelli wrote: In the Struts Users and Shale Users mailing lists we (Greg and I) encountered several people confused by the different meaning of tiles:insert, so we decided to specialize this tag in different tags, I chose only the names. And I don't think that anyone used

Re: [tiles2] Changes in tag libraries

2006-10-31 Thread Antonio Petrelli
[EMAIL PROTECTED] ha scritto: Antonio Petrelli wrote: In the Struts Users and Shale Users mailing lists we (Greg and I) encountered several people confused by the different meaning of tiles:insert, so we decided to specialize this tag in different tags, I chose only the names. And I don't

RE: [tiles2] Changes in tag libraries

2006-10-31 Thread George.Dinwiddie
, October 27, 2006 7:33 AM To: Struts Developers List Subject: [tiles2] Changes in tag libraries Hi As you may have seen, I replace tiles:insert tag with three specialized tags: tiles:insertDefinition, tiles:insertTemplate, tiles:attribute. I hope you don't hate me for the change :-) I

RE: [tiles2] Changes in tag libraries

2006-10-31 Thread George.Dinwiddie
Antonio Petrelli asked: [EMAIL PROTECTED] ha scritto: Antonio Petrelli wrote: In the Struts Users and Shale Users mailing lists we (Greg and I) encountered several people confused by the different meaning of tiles:insert, so we decided to specialize this tag in different tags,

Re: [tiles2] Changes in tag libraries

2006-10-31 Thread Antonio Petrelli
David H. DeWolf ha scritto: There are probably two types of people that will need to port: 1) Those that use tile. They register the listener and use the tags. (probably mostly Struts1 users) ... IMHO we should do everything possible to keep migration for #1 simple. ... The tag in question,

Re: [tiles2] Changes in tag libraries

2006-10-31 Thread Greg Reddin
I wonder if it would be possible to provide the combined tiles:insert tag as well for people who are porting applications. There are two questions that come to mind: 1) Have we already made porting to Tiles 2 a non-trivial task by all the changes we've made, and 2) are we ready for the

Re: [tiles2] Changes in tag libraries

2006-10-31 Thread David H. DeWolf
There are probably two types of people that will need to port: 1) Those that use tile. They register the listener and use the tags. (probably mostly Struts1 users) 2) Those that integrate tiles into their framework. They access the api and want to be able to customize it. IMHO we should

[tiles2] Changes in tag libraries

2006-10-27 Thread Antonio Petrelli
Hi As you may have seen, I replace tiles:insert tag with three specialized tags: tiles:insertDefinition, tiles:insertTemplate, tiles:attribute. I hope you don't hate me for the change :-) I thought that an eventual tiles:insertString is useless, since there are better tags to put strings.