RE: Unrestricted cross-signed Subordinate CA profile questions

2023-08-09 Thread 'Corey Bonnell' via dev-security-policy@mozilla.org
* The existence of this end-run around the system is why the current version of the BRs says "whether a Root CA Certificate or Subordinate CA Certificate". It's functionally impossible to truly distinguish between Roots and Intermediates (many or most CA keypairs are represented by both),

Re: MRSP 2.9: Final Review of MRSP 2.9

2023-08-09 Thread Ben Wilson
All, Over the past couple of weeks (after my previous email on July 27), I have made additional changes to the proposed MRSP v. 2.9, based on a more thorough review of the document and comments received. If you would like to review those more recent changes, they are shown in the following link:

Re: Unrestricted cross-signed Subordinate CA profile questions

2023-08-09 Thread 'Aaron Gable' via dev-security-policy@mozilla.org
(Apologies if you're seeing this twice, the thread got accidentally forked.) Hi all, Thanks to some off-list / backchannel conversations, I think I have a better understanding of what's going on here. Structurally, there is zero difference between: A) A keypair which is intended to be a Root,

Re: Unrestricted cross-signed Subordinate CA profile questions

2023-08-09 Thread Dimitris Zacharopoulos
[Re-sending because my mail client accidentally dropped the list address] Corey, The "corresponding root certificate" does not need to be included in the Mozilla Root Program which allows cross signing of CAs that are in the inclusion process. Thanks, Dimitris. Aug 8, 2023 23:27:13