MRSP 2.9: Draft CA Communication and Survey

2023-08-18 Thread Ben Wilson
All, Below for your review and comment is a draft CA Communication and Survey to be sent next week via the CCADB to all CA operators in Mozilla's root store. Thanks, Ben Mozilla CA Operator Survey - Respond By September 15, 2023Section 1: The purpose of this communication and survey is to ensure

Re: Mozilla Policy 2.9, section 3.1.4 and CCADB policy section 5.1

2023-08-18 Thread 'Aaron Poulsen' via dev-security-policy@mozilla.org
I do not feel this point it nitpicky. Externally-referenced documents increase the compliance burden on CAs (and organizations, in general) and introduce unnecessary complexity. Specifying a version is helpful, but we will also need to ensure prior versions of policies are easily accessible

Re: MRSP 2.9: S/MIME BRs and Audits

2023-08-18 Thread Ben Wilson
All, The language decided upon for item 3 of MRSP section 1.1 (Scope of MRSP for end entity certificates) is as follows: end entity certificates that have at least one valid, unrevoked chain up to such a CA certificate through intermediate certificates that are all in scope and - an EKU

Re: MRSP 2.9: Issues 261, 263 and 267, Miscellaneous Clarifications and Corrections

2023-08-18 Thread Ben Wilson
All, I don't believe we received any comments or questions, and the proposed changes have been made to the draft version of MRSP v.2.9. Therefore, I will assume that discussion of these issues can now be closed. Thanks, Ben On Thu, Jul 13, 2023 at 2:23 PM Ben Wilson wrote: > All, > > This email

Re: MRSP 2.9: Issue #250: Clarify MRSP 5.3.2 to expressly include revoked CA certificates

2023-08-18 Thread Ben Wilson
All, Here is the currently proposed language for the first paragraph of MRSP section 5.3.2: The operator of a CA certificate included in Mozilla’s root store MUST publicly disclose in the CCADB all CA certificates it issues that chain up to that CA certificate trusted in Mozilla’s root store that

Re: MRSP 2.9: Issue #239: Audit Statement Content

2023-08-18 Thread Ben Wilson
All, In response to Tim Hollebeek's recent email on this topic ( https://groups.google.com/a/mozilla.org/g/dev-security-policy/c/HJDtlQEfUsY/m/1t6s5G2rAgAJ), I have added a reference to CCADB Policy version 1.2.3. Unless there are additional comments, I am assuming that discussion on this topic

Re: MRSP 2.9: Issue #254: Harmonize CRL Reason Codes with CA/B Forum Revocation Reasons

2023-08-18 Thread Ben Wilson
All, Here are those changes as proposed in the previous email on this topic. https://github.com/BenWilson-Mozilla/pkipolicy/commit/644a665c434e6df8a4ab57e19583508d3fa7fcbd. The removed text can now be found here: