Re: [dmarc-ietf] Give up on SPF alone

2023-04-15 Thread Hector Santos
On 4/15/2023 11:27 AM, Douglas Foster wrote: Sorry Hector, but you are wrong on the theory and off topic. DMARC and SPF authenticate different things. DMARC is designed to override SPF Fail to handle the case of forwarding without SRS, which would be optimal if all messages were signed.

Re: [dmarc-ietf] Give up on SPF alone

2023-04-15 Thread Douglas Foster
Sorry Hector, but you are wrong on the theory and off topic. DMARC and SPF authenticate different things. DMARC is designed to override SPF Fail to handle the case of forwarding without SRS, which would be optimal if all messages were signed. Bandwidth optimization was an issue when we were on