Re: [Gendergap] Addressing incivility (was: men on lists)

2014-07-06 Thread Risker
A few points here: - If less than 15% of editors identify as female, and the vast majority of those do not regularly participate in dispute management, how are you going to establish a panel that is 50% women? This isn't a small point - there are so few individuals generally

Re: [Gendergap] Addressing incivility (was: men on lists)

2014-07-06 Thread Kerry Raymond
Being relatively new to this list, I dip my toe into what seems to be a somewhat fraught mailing list with some trepidation. (Read: please don't bite this newbie). I think we need to understand where the problems lie and therefore what problem(s) we are seeking to solve. If I understand it

Re: [Gendergap] Addressing incivility (was: men on lists)

2014-07-06 Thread Kathleen McCook
I have a class of many women who have an optional editing assignment,. Many try to edit but leave out of concern about bullying by (probably) male editors. You are right that they are lost before they get here. My attrition rate is 70%. I do not want women to go where they do not feel safe. I do