Re: [GNC-dev] Reports -- Cleanup

2019-01-09 Thread D via gnucash-devel
If the reports are getting some attention now, I'll note that there are a number of minor bugs in Bugzilla regarding reports that could use attention. I put in 773168, 773169, 773198, 773199, and 773200, which are all pretty superficial, IMHO, and might be despatched by someone with any skill

Re: [GNC-dev] Reports -- Cleanup

2019-01-09 Thread Stephen M. Butler
I appreciate all the responses.  The general consensus is to keep the existing options and build more specific reports on top of it's capabilities. From the comments, it appears a coder could hide many of the options in order to produce a targeted report that an end-user would find easier to use

Re: [GNC-dev] Reports -- Cleanup

2019-01-09 Thread Christopher Lam
Thanks for the interest in reports. I'd like to take opportunity to explain current state of code. Examples of duplication: - html-barchart, html-linechart, html-scatter, html-pie have a lot of duplicated code; there's a pending work for merging the charting infrastructure into a universal one,

Re: [GNC-dev] Reports -- Cleanup

2019-01-09 Thread Geert Janssens
Op dinsdag 8 januari 2019 18:25:33 CET schreef Stephen M. Butler: > On 1/7/19 8:42 PM, Adrien Monteleone wrote: > > I do agree however that the Transaction report is really more of a ‘master > > report’ of sorts. The multi-column is another. There might be others. > > > > Those should probably be

Re: [GNC-dev] Reports -- Cleanup

2019-01-08 Thread Stephen M. Butler
On 1/7/19 8:42 PM, Adrien Monteleone wrote: > Stephen, while I agree in principle that the reports need cleanup, as a user, > I don’t want to see functionality removed, just moved. Consider the following: > > For example on your #1, > > Why do I need to see the credit split for every transaction

Re: [GNC-dev] Reports -- Cleanup

2019-01-07 Thread Adrien Monteleone
Stephen, while I agree in principle that the reports need cleanup, as a user, I don’t want to see functionality removed, just moved. Consider the following: For example on your #1, Why do I need to see the credit split for every transaction when running the report for an expense account? Maybe

Re: [GNC-dev] Reports -- Cleanup

2019-01-07 Thread David T. via gnucash-devel
Stephen, I'm sure I would welcome improvement in the reports.  I don't have many concrete points here, except to suggest that the ideal UI point for a reconciliation report would be at the end of the reconciliation process. A check box on the reconcile window would trigger the report,

[GNC-dev] Reports -- Cleanup

2019-01-07 Thread Stephen M. Butler
I think one of the developers here mentioned that there is a lot of duplication in the reports arena.  I concur.  At first it was very confusing as to which was the "correct" one.  Finally figured out none where -- according to the in house SME (pronounced "smee" and standing for Subject Matter