Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-27 Thread Owen DeLong
On Jan 26, 2014, at 00:39 , Sander Steffann san...@steffann.nl wrote: Hi Owen, Same question… Will people adjust their filters, (even if only for that prefix)? All over the world? I think 'will adjust their filters for XYZ' is highly optimistic, but let's hope it will work, otherwise the

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-27 Thread Sander Steffann
But more important: which /10 is set aside for this? It is not listed on https://www.arin.net/knowledge/ip_blocks.html I'm not sure it has been determined yet, let alone announced. According to https://www.arin.net/resources/request/ipv4_countdown.html phase one it should have been

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-27 Thread Tore Anderson
* Sander Steffann But more important: which /10 is set aside for this? It is not listed on https://www.arin.net/knowledge/ip_blocks.html Probably 23.128/10: arin||ipv4|23.128.0.0|4194304||reserved| Tore

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-27 Thread Sander Steffann
Hi, Op 27 jan. 2014 om 10:49 heeft Tore Anderson t...@fud.no het volgende geschreven: * Sander Steffann But more important: which /10 is set aside for this? It is not listed on https://www.arin.net/knowledge/ip_blocks.html Probably 23.128/10:

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-27 Thread Patrick W. Gilmore
[...] particularly of policies defined by a handful of folks who bother to participate in the ARIN public policy processes I love this part. I was told a billion times where and how to participate in the policy debate - to the point where many people complain they are being told too many

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-27 Thread Jay Ashworth
- Original Message - From: John R. Levine jo...@iecc.com The customer continues to whine about performance. Our ISP says, ah, you need our Preferred Thoughput Upgrade Innovation (PTUI), available at modest extra cost. The extra cost, of course, it what it costs to buy a /24 and get

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-26 Thread Owen DeLong
On Jan 25, 2014, at 23:56 , Sander Steffann san...@steffann.nl wrote: Hi Owen, Op 26 jan. 2014, om 05:36 heeft Owen DeLong o...@delong.com het volgende geschreven: On Jan 25, 2014, at 13:59 , Sander Steffann san...@steffann.nl wrote: Hi, […] But, when that happens ARIN will only

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-26 Thread Sander Steffann
Hi Owen, Same question… Will people adjust their filters, (even if only for that prefix)? All over the world? I think 'will adjust their filters for XYZ' is highly optimistic, but let's hope it will work, otherwise the ISPs in the ARIN region will have a problem. (Or maybe not: existing

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-26 Thread Dave Bell
But more important: which /10 is set aside for this? It is not listed on https://www.arin.net/knowledge/ip_blocks.html 100.64/10 http://tools.ietf.org/search/rfc6598

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-26 Thread Randy Bush
sander, i suspect that, as multi-homing continues to grow and ipv4 space fragments to be used in core-facing nat[64]-like things, a decade from now we'll see the boundary move to the right. randy

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-26 Thread Alexander Neilson
Regards Alexander Alexander Neilson Neilson Productions Limited alexan...@neilson.net.nz 021 329 681 022 456 2326 On 26/01/2014, at 10:35 pm, Dave Bell m...@geordish.org wrote: But more important: which /10 is set aside for this? It is not listed on

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-26 Thread Sander Steffann
Hi, On 26/01/2014, at 10:35 pm, Dave Bell m...@geordish.org wrote: But more important: which /10 is set aside for this? It is not listed on https://www.arin.net/knowledge/ip_blocks.html 100.64/10 http://tools.ietf.org/search/rfc6598 Correct me if I am wrong but this is the space

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-26 Thread Sander Steffann
Hi Randy, i suspect that, as multi-homing continues to grow and ipv4 space fragments to be used in core-facing nat[64]-like things, a decade from now we'll see the boundary move to the right. Maybe, if the equipment can handle the number of routes. I actually see two opposing things: the

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-26 Thread John Levine
I wonder what will change (if anything) when ARIN runs out of IPv4 space. In routing, probably not much. The market in used IPv4 space will come out from the shadows, and we'll see endless arguments between buyers of IPv4 space and ARIN, when ARIN refuses the updates to the address registry. I

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-26 Thread David Conrad
On Jan 26, 2014, at 11:45 AM, John Levine jo...@iecc.com wrote: I wonder what will change (if anything) when ARIN runs out of IPv4 space. The market in used IPv4 space will come out from the shadows, It mostly has already done so in the APNIC and RIPE regions out of necessity. and we'll see

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-26 Thread John R. Levine
and we'll see endless arguments between buyers of IPv4 space and ARIN, when ARIN refuses the updates to the address registry. This would be bad. I can think of few more effective ways of destroying the RIR system than by refusing to update the address registry. I completely agree, but there

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-26 Thread Jimmy Hess
On Sun, Jan 26, 2014 at 8:02 PM, John R. Levine jo...@iecc.com wrote: I don't see ARIN recognizing bogus transfers in the registry -- if the transfer policy wasn't followed, then no transfer occurred. Well, maybe. My vision is that the ISP calls up their upstreams and/or peers, some say OK,

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-26 Thread John R. Levine
I don't see ARIN recognizing bogus transfers in the registry -- if the transfer policy wasn't followed, then no transfer occurred. I expect the party that paid good money for the address space, and the party who they paid, and their respective attorneys, will strenously disagree with you, but

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-26 Thread Masataka Ohta
Sander Steffann wrote: i suspect that, as multi-homing continues to grow and ipv4 space fragments to be used in core-facing nat[64]-like things, a decade from now we'll see the boundary move to the right. Maybe, if the equipment can handle the number of routes. I actually see two opposing

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-26 Thread Randy Bush
I don't see ARIN recognizing bogus transfers in the registry -- if the transfer policy wasn't followed, then no transfer occurred. do you share what you are smoking?

Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-25 Thread Drew Linsalata
Yeah, its been a while since I had to get involved in this. We have a customer with their own IPv4 allocation that wants us to announce a /27 for them. Back in the day, it was /24 or larger or all bets were off. Is that still the case now?

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-25 Thread Seth Mattinen
On 1/25/14, 13:17, Drew Linsalata wrote: Yeah, its been a while since I had to get involved in this. We have a customer with their own IPv4 allocation that wants us to announce a /27 for them. Back in the day, it was /24 or larger or all bets were off. Is that still the case now? /24

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-25 Thread Laszlo Hanyecz
Yes, a /27 is too small. You need at least a /24. On Jan 25, 2014, at 9:17 PM, Drew Linsalata drew.linsal...@gmail.com wrote: Yeah, its been a while since I had to get involved in this. We have a customer with their own IPv4 allocation that wants us to announce a /27 for them. Back in the

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-25 Thread Christopher Morrow
On Sat, Jan 25, 2014 at 4:17 PM, Drew Linsalata drew.linsal...@gmail.com wrote: Yeah, its been a while since I had to get involved in this. We have a customer with their own IPv4 allocation that wants us to announce a /27 for them. Back in the day, it was /24 or larger or all bets were off.

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-25 Thread Justin M. Streiner
On Sat, 25 Jan 2014, Drew Linsalata wrote: Yeah, its been a while since I had to get involved in this. We have a customer with their own IPv4 allocation that wants us to announce a /27 for them. Back in the day, it was /24 or larger or all bets were off. Is that still the case now? Things

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-25 Thread Sander Steffann
Hi, Yeah, its been a while since I had to get involved in this. We have a customer with their own IPv4 allocation that wants us to announce a /27 for them. Back in the day, it was /24 or larger or all bets were off. Is that still the case now? This is still the case today. I wonder what

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-25 Thread Jeff Kell
(snip) I doubt that anything /24 will ever be eligible as a portable provider independent block. If within a provider, you can slice and dice as you wish. Jeff

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-25 Thread Sander Steffann
Hi, Op 25 jan. 2014, om 23:05 heeft Jeff Kell jeff-k...@utc.edu het volgende geschreven: (snip) I doubt that anything /24 will ever be eligible as a portable provider independent block. If within a provider, you can slice and dice as you wish. Sure, but the text I quoted is about ARIN

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-25 Thread Phil Fagan
I would imagine this should be announced with the larger block owner. On Jan 25, 2014 2:19 PM, Drew Linsalata drew.linsal...@gmail.com wrote: Yeah, its been a while since I had to get involved in this. We have a customer with their own IPv4 allocation that wants us to announce a /27 for them.

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-25 Thread Jimmy Hess
On Sat, Jan 25, 2014 at 4:15 PM, Sander Steffann san...@steffann.nl wrote: Sure, but the text I quoted is about ARIN allocations, so ARIN - ISP. So the /28 is not provider-independent. It *is* the provider... And yes: I think this will become a mess in ARIN land :( There aren't any /27 or

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-25 Thread Sander Steffann
Hi Jimmy, There aren't any /27 or /28 Allocations from ARIN to an ISP A /28 is longer than the ARIN Minimum allocation block size of /22, and longer than the minimum transfer size of a /24 block. Now: yes. Soon: no. Read https://www.arin.net/policy/nrpm.html#four10 Sander

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-25 Thread Owen DeLong
On Jan 25, 2014, at 13:59 , Sander Steffann san...@steffann.nl wrote: Hi, Yeah, its been a while since I had to get involved in this. We have a customer with their own IPv4 allocation that wants us to announce a /27 for them. Back in the day, it was /24 or larger or all bets were off. Is

Re: Will a single /27 get fully routed these days?

2014-01-25 Thread Sander Steffann
Hi Owen, Op 26 jan. 2014, om 05:36 heeft Owen DeLong o...@delong.com het volgende geschreven: On Jan 25, 2014, at 13:59 , Sander Steffann san...@steffann.nl wrote: Hi, […] But, when that happens ARIN will only have the 'Dedicated IPv4 block to facilitate IPv6 Deployment' [1] left, and