Hi Samita and Daniel, On Tuesday 27 June 2006 04:05, Samita Chakrabarti wrote: > Hi Daniel, > > Please see my comments in-line. > > > > Erik and I have updated > > > draft-chakrabarti-6lowpan-ipv6-nd-02.txt and submitted for > > > publication. The new update includes a section on generic > > > application of this draft for non-multicast, non-broadcast > > > network. At the last wg meeting, the request was made for such > > > an update for the Wimax effort on IPv6. > > > > Let me clarify one point, > > > > I remember the relevent discussion in Dallas. Yes, we definitely > > need this aspect, however 16ng WG (IP over IEEE 802.16) > > has been newly created in INT area and they will take care of > > this issue as one of WG deliverable. So, please toss it to that. > > There is no conflict with 16ng ND with this work. As Erik and > Basavaraj mentioned > before that we need to make sure that 6lowpan-ND and 16ng ND > modifications do not provide different solutions for the same > problem. Because the solution presented in 6lowpan-ND document can > be generally applicable to any other non-multicast/broadcast > energy-efficient network (16ng is one of the immediate > applications), the 'general applicability' of this > draft may be useful for other type of power efficient networks as > well. > > Thus the idea is that 16ng-ND draft can update its text based on > the information in the general applicability section of the > 6lowpan-ND draft.
Until today I was unaware of existence of Relay-DAD in 6lowpan and 16ng (silly me ;-) As I mentionned already on the 16ng mailing list today: <http://eeca16.sogang.ac.kr/pipermail/16ng/Week-of-Mon-20060626/000165.html> In a draft I co-author (available there until it shows up in ID rep: (<http://julien.laganier.free.fr/draft-ietf-netlmm-mn-ar-if-01.txt) we also define Relay-DAD to support SEND (otherwise we could just have proxied ND.) Hence, I thought I should also ask to this mailing list opinions on usefulness of a standalone document defining Relay-DAD? Thanks, --julien _______________________________________________ 6lowpan mailing list [email protected] https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/6lowpan
