> I think mx record is required in official dns server,
> although I feel  the condition is too strict.

Keep in mind that a DNS *failure* is not the same thing
as a particular DNS record not existing.

If you ask whether there is an MX record for foo, and
get a timeout, you can't assume there is not an MX
record for foo and "fall back" on the A query.

Misconfigured DNS servers with some frequency will
return SERVFAIL ("I am misconfigured or broken") to
an MX query while happily answering A queries.

The right thing is to request the administrator of
that domain to return an MX record to the MX query
or to return zero records.

Dave Eckhardt

Reply via email to