On Tue, 07 Oct 2008, Michael Putch wrote: > I have notice that the Linux distribution of Activeperl contains > both the "regular" build of Perl and debug build (i.e. build with > -DDEBUGGING in order to support the -D family of debugging options), > but the Windows distribution doesn't. I know I could just build it > from source, but this disparity strikes me as puzzling. > Traditionally it has been somewhat easier to build Perl under Linux > et all than under Windows, so if anything I would have expected it > to be the other way around. Thanks in advance!
It is actually easier to combine a debugging and non-debugging build on Unix than on Windows: On Unix perl-debugging is statically linked with libperl.so and can therefore live in the same tree as the non- debugging perl-static and perl-dynamic versions. On Windows Perl is always dynamically linking against perl58.dll or perl510.dll. So to create a debugging perl-debugging.exe we would also have to create a perl510-debugging.dll to link against. And then we may even have to have to separately compile all extension modules too, because they want to resolve their symbols against perl510.dll and not perl510-debugging.dll. But those extensions would then have to live in a separate directory tree because they would have all the same names as the non-debugging modules. It may be possible to play some tricks, like having a perl510-debugging.dll which internally claims to be perl510.dll. Then maybe the Windows loader would resolve additional symbols against this library instead. But this will require additional development effort to figure out if it is feasible, and then update the automated ActivePerl build processes to build this non-standard configuration and merge it into the normal ActivePerl release. That's really the only reason why there isn't a perl-debugging in the Windows distribution. It is on our "wish-list", but it has a relatively low priority. Cheers, -Jan _______________________________________________ ActivePerl mailing list [email protected] To unsubscribe: http://listserv.ActiveState.com/mailman/mysubs
