Congrats my friend ! 2017-08-28 12:24 GMT+01:00 abdelwaheb turki <[email protected]>:
> > > Dear Mr. or Ms., > > I thank you for your support to my AICCSA paper. This is an honour of me. > I have done quite all the required revisions. However, its English is still > not proofread. I ask if you can verify and adjust the language quality of > my AICCSA paper. It is currently available in https://1drv.ms/w/s! > AiC69hcGxSVPl1UI1SV81mkr2uVu. As for the grant to attend AICCSA 2017, you > can still endorse it in https://meta.wikimedia.org/ > wiki/Grants:Project/Rapid/Csisc/Presenting_Wikidata_for_ > Arab_Computational_Linguists. > <https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Project/Rapid/Csisc/Presenting_Wikidata_for_Arab_Computational_Linguists> > > Yours Sincerely, > > Houcemeddine Turki > > <https://1drv.ms/w/s!AiC69hcGxSVPl1UI1SV81mkr2uVu> > <https://1drv.ms/w/s!AiC69hcGxSVPl1UI1SV81mkr2uVu> > AICCSA-Copie-_2_ 2.docx <https://1drv.ms/w/s!AiC69hcGxSVPl1UI1SV81mkr2uVu> > Partagé via OneDrive > > > > > ------------------------------ > *De :* ANLP2017 <[email protected]> > *Envoyé :* mercredi 16 août 2017 00:53 > *À :* Houcemeddine Turki > *Objet :* ANLP2017 notification for paper 3 > > Dear Dr.Houcemeddine Turki > > Congratulations! On behalf of the ANLP 2017 workshop and Conference > Committees of the 14th ACS/IEEE International Conference on Computer > Systems and Applications AICCSA 2017, October 30th to November 3rd, 2017. > we are happy to inform you that your paper entitled: > > Using WikiData to create a multi-lingual multi-dialectal dictionary for > Arabic dialects > > has been accepted for presentation and inclusion in the Proceedings of > AICCSA - ANLP 2017, published by IEEE. > > > Please see the reviewers’ comments below on your paper. These comments are > intended to help you to improve your paper for final publication. The > listed comments should be addressed, as final acceptance is conditional > upon appropriate response to the requirements and comments. The conference > committee retains a list of certain critical comments to be addressed by > authors, and will control that these have been addressed in the > camera-ready version. > > > What is next: > ------------- > The AICCSA website is updated now with required information. Please find > below the details for the camera ready submission and the registration. > > Camera ready submission: > Due date: 31/8/2017 > Submission information can be found at the following link: > http://www.aiccsa.net/AICCSA2017/submission > > Final Camera Ready and copyright instructions > <http://www.aiccsa.net/AICCSA2017/submission> > www.aiccsa.net > 14th ACS/IEEE International Conference on Computer Systems and > Applications AICCSA 2017 October 30th to November 3rd, 2017 > > > > > Paper Registration: > Due date: 8/9/2017 > The registration information can be found at the following link: > http://www.aiccsa.net/AICCSA2017/registration > > Registration - AICCSA <http://www.aiccsa.net/AICCSA2017/registration> > www.aiccsa.net > 14th ACS/IEEE International Conference on Computer Systems and > Applications AICCSA 2017 October 30th to November 3rd, 2017 > > > > > We are looking to meet you in AICCSA 2017. > > Best Regards, > > AICCSA - ANLP 2017 Organization Team. > > ============================== > > > ----------------------- REVIEW 1 --------------------- > PAPER: 3 > TITLE: Using WikiData to create a multi-lingual multi-dialectal dictionary > for Arabic dialects > AUTHORS: Houcemeddine Turki, Denny Vrandečić, Helmi Hamdi and Imed Adel > > Overall evaluation: 1 (weak accept) > > ----------- Overall evaluation ----------- > It is an interesting work with valid assumption and its proposed ideas > also in line with the expectation of the event. Overall, I think, this > paper is interesting and has good contribution to this topic. However, the > authors are advised to have the following points on their revised version: > -Please elaborate in details about the proposed approach with more > focusing on the relations between its components, as they are the core of > the solution and need more justification of why to use them. > -Overall technical exposition must be strengthened with more concrete > examples. > -The authors are urged to summarize and list the key observations from the > paper. > -The paper is readable but a language improvement using a native speaker > is recommended. > -Some minor editorial issue, like enhancing the plots quality, the > equations, etc... > -Many reference are with *incomplete* bibliographic information (like lack > of publication venue, for instance). This must be corrected. > > In summery, it a well prepared paper. > > > ----------------------- REVIEW 2 --------------------- > PAPER: 3 > TITLE: Using WikiData to create a multi-lingual multi-dialectal dictionary > for Arabic dialects > AUTHORS: Houcemeddine Turki, Denny Vrandečić, Helmi Hamdi and Imed Adel > > Overall evaluation: 0 (borderline paper) > > ----------- Overall evaluation ----------- > The paper technical content is very marginal, the paper has many language > and editorial issue, > a better results presentation and figs quality are needed. i guess the > paper is not ready for publication yet. > > Other issues to be considered too: > > - The paper lacks clarity in motivating the proposed research and in > stating its expected outcome > - the review of the state of the art lacks an analysis of the existing > work and the positioning of the research in the state of the art > - The methodology is too general and does not convincingly show the > feasibility of the proposed approach > - the research lacks a concrete illustration on a case study. > > recommendation to the authors > - to clearly state the objective of the research in terms of problems to > address and expected results and show how the proposed research will > advance the state of the art by > overcoming the limitations of the existing work > - to preset an analysis of the state of the art and discuss the > benefits/limitations of the existing approaches with respect to the > addressed research problem > - to be more precise in the description of the methodology and show how > the methodology would achieve the stated objectives > - to discuss the future plans with respect to the research state of > progress and its limitations > > There is serious issue with many editorials in the paper that need to be > fixed, many of the figs are fuzzy and need to be reconsidered again. > > > _______________________________________________ > African-Wikimedians mailing list > [email protected] > https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/african-wikimedians > > -- *Sami Mlouhi* *Member of Wikimedia TN User Group.*
_______________________________________________ African-Wikimedians mailing list [email protected] https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/african-wikimedians
