On Wed, Nov 18, 2026, 8:09 AM John Rose via AGI <[email protected]> wrote:
> Here's some reasonable insight for those seeking clarity: > > > https://www.academia.edu/3071-4087/2/3/10.20935/AcadNeurosci8547?email_action=download > The author defines free will as the capability of modifying one's own predisposition to make future choices rather than the ability to make immediate choices. For example, a thermostat does not have free will because it cannot change its temperature setting. Then he claims that only humans and not other animals have free will because only humans can decide how they plan to make future choices. He claims this is because of more connections between the medial prefrontal cortex and the posterior cingulate cortex, which do not exist in other species. OK, but so what? When you make a choice, it feels like you could have chosen otherwise, even if the choice was deterministically made by neurons following the laws of physics. Maybe other animals have this same feeling. It's hard to test because they lack language and we can't ask them. Maybe that's the reason for the different brain structure. Humans really aren't smarter than other animals at skills not involving language, such as hunting, foraging, and avoiding predators. Is the author opposing animal rights? We are taught that it is wrong to cause suffering in other people. Suffering is different from pain. Pain is a signal that alters your behavior to avoid the thing that caused it. Without free will, that behavior is just a reflex, no different than positive reinforcement of the opposite action. But if you believe that you had a choice to not avoid it but did anyway, then you interpret your action as done out of fear of suffering. And what does this imply about free will in AI? If a machine passes the Turing test, then it certainly appears to have free will just as much as any human, even though we know that its actions are the result of a deterministic program trained to predict text. Is the question even important? AI was solved by people who considered free will and consciousness to be irrelevant distractions. ------------------------------------------ Artificial General Intelligence List: AGI Permalink: https://agi.topicbox.com/groups/agi/T4476aab566b1f3f8-M6b5f5b9d58a20b6ba22a2364 Delivery options: https://agi.topicbox.com/groups/agi/subscription
