Sergio,
I think brains are classical devices as well, although I also
believe there to be a difference between simple classical systems and
systems exhibiting a "complexity threshold". When you introduce enough
autonomous agents into a "system", the emergent behavior generates a new
threshold. And this process is recursive, so that once a threshold is
met, another new "system" is coined. There are no definite "threshold
levels" but rather vague analog tipping points depending on the
characteristics of the input system. Thus, nth level systems (cognition
-> biological learning algorithms -> neurons -> molecules -> atoms ->
sub-atomic systems -> universal constant limits, etc) are exchanging
evolutionary "information" with each other, and cross-influencing each
others behavior.
This brings us to orders of magnitude and the hierarchal
perspective. Successful evolutionary growth tends to have higher level
systems (person) that see its "lower systems" (cells) as expendable, but
higher forms (society) as worth more than itself. From a certain
vantage point on this hierarchy, a "low" enough system is replaceable by
a process that is able to predict an outcome or output up to an
unimportant round (ie analog vs. digital). My dilemma occurs when
consciousness comes into the picture. There may be a certain point
where "existing", in the way we understand it, parallels some universal
constant or "planck time persistence". This trait may not follow into
our AGI systems. We might be taking the same "evolutionary road" as our
AI, but they lack the quantum parallel necessary to be conscious.
Perhaps "systemic" cognition and true consciousness are separable? A
cognitive "understanding of systems" might itself be a higher, yet
unnecessary step up from "conscious cognition". So the question would
become, are cognitive systems or consciousness more important to
reproduce first?
Sorry about the bad english/vagueness. Lunch came and went a little too
fast today for any editing.
-Josh
--
This message has been scanned for viruses and
dangerous content by MailScanner, and is
believed to be clean.
-----
This list is sponsored by AGIRI: http://www.agiri.org/email
To unsubscribe or change your options, please go to:
http://v2.listbox.com/member/[EMAIL PROTECTED]