I have sent a message textually identical to the text below before;
however, I am resending it to perform the actions in it again.
ehird wrote:
> 2008/6/20 comex <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>:
> > TtPF: I did not post the message on my forum containing the text
> > {{comex deregisters.}}.
>
> I initiate a criminal CFJ against comex for violating rule 2149 for
> lying in the quoted message.
>
> Evidence: comex posted the message in question.
ehird: how can you possibly know that? I could have posted the
message, for instance. (I didn't, but for all you know I could have
done, unless of course you posted that message yourself.) Likewise,
for all I know it could have been one of the other Agora players,
or a non-Agoran. It seems... reckless to assert that comex made that
statement with no evidence.
I initiate a criminal CFJ against ehird for violating rule 2149 by
knowingly or recklessly making a false statement. (Disclaimer:
although it seems unlikely to me, it is still possible that comex
did in fact make that statement, so the statement that I alleged in
that CFJ is not necessarily true on the evidence I know, and one
reason to file a CFJ, even a criminal one, is to determine whether
its statement is true or false.)
Evidence:
This message, including the bit it quotes.
I may also be able to provide other evidence on request from the
judge of the case.
Arguments:
Because there seems to be no way that ehird could know that the
statement "comex posted the message in question" is true, then
if it turns out to be false it was made either knowingly or
recklessly, and it seems to me overwhelmingly likely that that
statement is in fact false.
--
ais523
