========================= Criminal Case 2307 =========================
The PerlNomic Partnership violated Rule 2215 by announcing that
I {Warrigal} am a party to it in the quoted message.
========================================================================
The PNP log shows:
1. The Caller emself caused the PNP to send the message in question.
2. At the time of the message in question, a proposal in PNP was
being prepared to remove the Caller from the PNP.
I find it difficult to conclude that a non-member of the PNP would be
able to trigger such functionality of the PNP with intent to decieve
Agora about that person's membership in the PNP. Without strong
evidence to the contrary, I conclude that the Caller was acting as if
e was a party to the PNP at the time in question. The effort to
remove em from the Partnership shows that the other parties were also
acting as if the Caller was a party.
I conclude that the PNP did not act with intent to mislead Agora
(guilt statement a), and so I rule NOT GUILTY.
Trial Judge OscarMeyr
Evidence: The relevant portion of the PerlNomic log.
Tue Dec 9 20:38:54 2008 - update_agora.cgi: ihope sent a message
with subject 'PNP Parties Change' to Agora.
Tue Dec 9 20:54:33 2008 - propose.cgi: woggle proposed
proposal.woggle.expel_ihope.
Tue Dec 9 20:54:45 2008 - edit_proposal.cgi: woggle edited
proposal.woggle.expel_ihope.
Tue Dec 9 20:55:06 2008 - edit_proposal.cgi: woggle edited
proposal.woggle.expel_ihope.
Tue Dec 9 20:55:06 2008 - edit_proposal.cgi: woggle closed
proposal.woggle.expel_ihope.
Tue Dec 9 20:55:19 2008 - vote.cgi: woggle voted yes on
woggle.expel_ihope(+1/-0/~0/8).
Wed Dec 10 03:50:10 2008 - vote.cgi: Wooble voted yes on
woggle.expel_ihope(+2/-0/~0/8).
Wed Dec 10 04:12:59 2008 - vote.cgi: ihope voted no on
woggle.expel_ihope(+2/-1/~0/8).
-----
Benjamin Schultz KE3OM
