The following is a Win Announcement:
root and coppro have scores x + yi such that xy >= 2500.
Explanation:
Last Monday, root issued a Scorekeepor's report with both emself and
myself listed as having 50 + 50i points. points are assets, so that
portion of the report is self-ratifying. I issued three CoEs against the
report - one alleging that Murphy's score was incorrect, one alleging
that my score was incorrect, and one alleging that root's score was
incorrect.
The first CoE was blatantly incorrect. After accepting the latter two,
root later denied it. According to rule 2201, { If e denies the claim,
then the original document is ratified one week after the denial, unless
it is challenged again (subject to the same requirements) during that
period.} The document was not challenged during that period, as such, it
has now ratified as it has been more than one week since the denial.
Now, since someone is no doubt going to do this anyway, I might as well
get the jump on this. I CFJ {coppro has won the game at least once.}
I also submit a proposal entitled {Fix self-ratification}, AI 3, II 3,
with the following text:
{{{
Amend rule 2201 by replacing:
{{
b) A claim of error, appropriate for matters of fact. The
publisher of the original document SHALL respond to a claim
of error as soon as possible, either publishing a revision or
denying the claim. If e denies the claim, then the original
document is ratified one week after the denial, unless it is
challenged again (subject to the same requirements) during
that period.
}}
with
{{
b) A claim of error, appropriate for matters of fact. The
publisher of the original document SHALL respond to a claim
of error as soon as possible, either publishing a revision or
denying the claim. Until e does so, the claim is outstanding.
After a claim is denied, the original document is ratified one
week after the denial, unless it is challenged again (subject
to the same requirements) during that period, there is an
outstanding claim at the time of the denial, or the officer has
published a revision to the document as required by this rule.
}}
}}}
