I announce that I deregister the President.

I call a CFJ on the statement "The president has been deregistered"
submitting the following statement/evidence:


Rule 2326/2 states "The President is a second-class person.  Causing the
President to act is secured."

The term "Secured" is not defined anywhere in the rules, hence I argue it
hasn't really got any legal meaning - does it mean that, once caused to act
no-one can undo the action, or that no-one can cause the president to act in
ways not defined in the rules? This ambiguity robs the second sentance of
all legal weight.

 Rule 869/32 states "A player who is not a person and has never been a
first-class person CAN be deregistered by any player by announcement."

This conflicts with:

"A first-class Player CAN cause the President to take actions Without
Objection, or with Agoran Consent." (Rule 2326/2).

Summarising rule 1030/9, to determine which statement takes precedence:

- Power (both rules are Power 2)
- Neither calls for alternative method for precidence.
- Neither claims precidence over, nor defers to the other explicitly.
- Rule 869/32 has the lower ID number, and hence takes precidence.

Therefore the president can be deregistered by announcement.


Arkady.

Reply via email to